Andrew Huberman explains the neuroscience of nicotine and how to quit smoking or vaping
A solo educational episode from the Huberman Lab Essentials series on nicotine's effects on the brain and body.
Summary
Andrew Huberman, neuroscientist and professor at Stanford School of Medicine, delivers a comprehensive breakdown of how nicotine works in the brain and body, separating nicotine itself from the delivery devices used to consume it. He explains that nicotine activates three major neurochemical pathways — dopamine, acetylcholine, and norepinephrine — which together produce heightened mood, focus, and alertness, making it one of the most powerful cognitive-enhancing substances known. He argues that while nicotine itself is not a carcinogen, every common delivery method — smoking, vaping, dipping, and snuffing — causes serious and well-documented harm, including a 14-year reduction in lifespan per pack smoked per day and a 50-fold increase in mouth cancers from dipping. The episode also covers why quitting is so difficult neurobiologically, with a 95% failure rate for cold-turkey attempts, and presents evidence-based methods for cessation including clinical hypnosis developed at Stanford by Dr. David Spiegel, the drug bupropion, and staged nicotine replacement therapy using patches, gum, and nasal spray in rotation.
Key Takeaways
FULL TRANSCRIPT
Introduction: Separating Nicotine from Its Delivery Devices
Andrew Huberman: Today we are discussing nicotine. Nicotine is one of the most commonly consumed substances on the entire planet. We are going to separate our discussion of nicotine from a discussion of smoking and vaping and the other forms of delivery for nicotine. We will be talking about smoking and vaping and other routes of nicotine administration, both for the sake of highlighting their detriments to health and — believe it or not, in certain very specific cases — the possible health benefits of delivering nicotine through specific modalities. It turns out those modalities do not include smoking cigarettes or vaping.
Let's talk about nicotine and how it impacts our brains, our bodies, our mental performance, our mental health, our physical performance, and our physical health. And I want to remind everybody that we really need to separate out a discussion about nicotine from the discussion about the delivery device for nicotine. In other words, when we're talking about nicotine, we are not necessarily talking about smoking, although we might be.
We think of nicotine as something that we take, but actually we have receptors — locations in the brain to which nicotine binds and can exert its effects. And those receptors did not come about because of the existence of tobacco or the existence of vaping pens or because of the existence of anything in the outside world. The fact that there are nicotinic receptors in our brain and body tells you that acetylcholine and nicotine themselves have very important roles in normal brain and body function.
Nicotine is a substance that can both promote cognitive function and, under some conditions — if taken to inappropriate or extreme dosages — can also impair cognitive function. Nicotine can be very powerful as a mood modulator, and many people who have tried to quit nicotine, mainly through the form of smoking, will find that their mood can drop substantially.
What Nicotine Is and Where It Comes From
So what is nicotine and where is it found? Obviously nicotine is found in the tobacco plant, but nicotine is also found in nightshades — that is, tomatoes, eggplants, and sweet peppers. Burning tobacco leads to a heat-induced change in the availability of nicotine. This is why smoking tobacco or vaping tobacco simply by heating it up allows the nicotine to be liberated and go into the bloodstream simply by inhaling it into the lungs.
Now, whether by inhalation or by placing it in contact with the mucosal tissue of the mouth or other mucosal-containing orifice of the body, the nicotine then gets into the bloodstream. And once it's in the bloodstream, it only exerts its effects because it binds to certain so-called nicotinic receptors. The nicotinic receptors are of the acetylcholine variety. There are a lot of different nicotinic acetylcholine receptors, but the main effects of nicotine in the brain are mediated by nicotine binding to the so-called alpha-4 beta-2 receptor. Even if you don't care about receptor subtypes, that's going to come up later when we discuss why nicotine suppresses appetite.
How Nicotine Enters the Bloodstream
When you ingest nicotine by smoking nicotine-containing tobacco, or if you place tobacco in contact with the mucosal lining of the nasal passages or the mouth, it takes about two to fifteen minutes for that nicotine to enter the bloodstream. Smoking hits the bloodstream faster. Vaping even faster, for a variety of reasons. And placing tobacco directly in contact with the mucosal lining is going to be the slowest.
The Three Neurochemical Pathways: Dopamine, Acetylcholine, and Norepinephrine
The first major neurochemical effect is one that I think not just all scientists but all human beings should know about. Within the brain, there is what is called the mesolimbic reward pathway. The mesolimbic reward pathway — if you just want to call it the dopamine reward pathway — is a set of connections between a brain area called the ventral tegmental area, or VTA, which connects to another area called the nucleus accumbens. Nicotine triggers the release of dopamine from the nucleus accumbens. This is what gives nicotine its rewarding properties. It increases motivation. It tends to give a not-so-subtle but very transient increase in feelings of well-being, alertness, and motivation. That's because of the increase in dopamine caused by nicotine directly within the nucleus accumbens.
Nicotine also triggers the release of certain neurochemicals from the ventral tegmental area itself, and those impinge on the nucleus accumbens and increase dopamine levels further. This is what makes the rewarding properties — sometimes referred to as the reinforcing properties — of nicotine so powerful. This is why so many people ingest nicotine in one form or another. It's also why nicotine is so hard to quit, because there's a potent increase in dopamine from multiple neural circuit pathways within this mesolimbic reward circuitry.
The second major effect that nicotine has in the brain is that it increases acetylcholine. Acetylcholine is a neuromodulator that exists in all of us. It is released from multiple sites in the brain, and the two major sites are the nucleus basalis — a collection of neurons in the front and base of your brain — and from some brainstem areas. Acetylcholine released from the nucleus basalis leads to a sort of spotlighting or highlighting of particular neural circuits in the brain. The neurons are there in the base of the brain but they extend axons — like little wires — elsewhere in the brain. When acetylcholine is released, it tends to be released at particular locations associated with whatever activity we happen to be doing. So it's literally like a neurochemical attentional spotlight.
Nicotine increases acetylcholine and thereby focus, concentration, and mental performance — not by changing the neural circuits that are activated per se, but rather by making more acetylcholine available at those release sites. Because of the pharmacokinetics — the time course in which nicotine has its effects, which are pretty short-lived — this enhancement in cognitive performance and attention is going to be very transient, probably on the order of about 30 to maybe 45 minutes.
So what we have is a scenario where dopamine is going up in the mesolimbic pathway — that's why smoking or ingesting nicotine in any other way feels good and makes us feel motivated — and then the increase in acetylcholine, especially from the nucleus basalis in the front of the brain, is the reason why it can increase our ability to focus on particular types of endeavors, particular mental work, or maybe even particular physical work.
The third neurochemical pathway that's strongly activated when nicotine enters the central nervous system is epinephrine — and in particular norepinephrine, which is related to epinephrine. Nicotine accomplishes those increases in alertness, arousal, and energy within the brain by triggering the release of norepinephrine from a little cluster of neurons in the back of the brain called the locus coeruleus. When that combines with the acetylcholine from the nucleus basalis — which causes attentional spotlighting, increases in concentration and focus — and with the feel-good and motivating properties of dopamine released from the mesolimbic reward pathway, you can start to get a picture of why nicotine is such a powerful molecule. It's making people feel motivated and good. It's making people feel focused. And it makes people feel alert when they would otherwise feel a little bit sleepy.
This is a really powerful compound — so powerful, in fact, that we can place nicotine right up there at the top, next to caffeine, as the molecule that has fundamentally changed human evolution, human consciousness, and human experience.
Nicotine's Effects on Appetite and Metabolism
Earlier I mentioned the appetite-suppressing and metabolism-increasing effects of nicotine. While that's a fairly niche component of what nicotine does, it is an important one. Within the hypothalamus, there's a compact collection of neurons referred to as the POMC neurons. The name comes from the fact that they express certain peptides. It turns out that when nicotine gets into the bloodstream and then into the brain, some of that nicotine binds to nicotinic alpha-4 beta-2 containing receptors. The nicotine binds to one of those receptor sites, and as a consequence these POMC neurons increase their electrical activity and appetite is suppressed.
In addition to limiting appetite by changing one's desire to ingest food and actual craving of food by regulation of blood sugar, there do seem to be some quite direct effects of nicotine on metabolism. The effects on metabolism aren't enormous — these are increases of about 2% up to about 5%. And I want to emphasize that those are transient increases in metabolism. Nonetheless, people who quit smoking often find that their appetite goes up.
Nicotine's Cardiovascular and Physical Effects
When nicotine makes it into the bloodstream — again within 2 to 15 minutes of ingesting it, depending on the delivery device — your heart rate will increase, blood pressure will increase, and the contractility of the heart tissue will actually increase. This is an increase in the sympathetic activity of the autonomic nervous system, which is a generalized system that increases levels of alertness and physical readiness. It makes you ready for action, makes you ready for thought.
So nicotine increases heart rate, blood pressure, and contractility of the heart. It's going to cause more blood flow in theory, although it also tends to constrict blood vessels in many locations in the body. This explains the decrease in penile girth effect of nicotine — in particular nicotine ingested by smoking or vaping. Smoking and vaping reduces penis size and will also have damaging effects on the blood-lining endothelial tissue.
What's interesting about nicotine is that while it causes this global increase in readiness, alertness, attention, and mood, it also has the effect of somewhat relaxing skeletal muscle.
Why Nicotine Suits Cognitive Work but Not Physical Performance
If we zoom out and think about the effects of nicotine, we have a very clear picture. Reward pathways are turned on. Attention is turned on. Alertness is turned on. You feel better than you felt a few minutes ago. Your blood pressure is up. Your heart rate is up. Your preparedness for thinking is elevated. And yet your body is somewhat relaxed. That's a very interesting state of mind and body — interesting because it's somewhat ideal for cognitive work. Being very alert while your body is relaxed is almost, if not the optimal state for getting mental work done.
It's also the exact opposite of the optimal state for physical performance, which requires not only alertness, motivation, and elevated mood, but also fast reaction time and low latency for muscle activation so that you can make coordinated muscle movements — which is of course what's required of physical endeavors.
That tells us a few things. First of all, nicotine is going to be generally a bad idea as a pre-workout tool or for enhancing physical performance. However, nicotine does seem to be very good at enhancing cognitive function, at least in the short term — which is not to say that it isn't without its side effects, which we will talk about.
The Dangers of Different Delivery Methods
Those side effects are independent of smoking or vaping or other forms of ingesting nicotine. For instance, dipping or chewing tobacco is known to cause a 50-fold — yes, 50-fold — increase in mouth cancers, things like leukoplakia, and is generally terrible for your health. So it's not just that smoking and vaping are bad for your health. These other forms of nicotine delivery can be bad for your health as well.
Right now, it appears that provided the dosages are kept reasonable and the frequency is kept relatively low — so not relying on these things constantly — there may in fact be some benefit to ingesting nicotine from time to time, provided that you are not still developing your brain. Certainly for people before puberty, during puberty, and probably for the next 15 to 20 years after puberty, avoiding nicotine is probably a good idea. For those of you that are 15 years old or younger, ingesting nicotine in any form, unless it's prescribed by your doctor for a very specific clinical reason, seems like a terrible idea based on all the data that I've read.
For people who are 25 years or older — and again, that's not a strict cutoff, but roughly 25 years or older — for those thinking about using nicotine to enhance cognitive function as adults whose brain development is slowing down, there may be instances in which increasing acetylcholine, dopamine, and so on by way of nicotine ingestion might be a good idea. But certainly not by smoking, vaping, or by direct contact of tobacco to the mucosal lining tissue of the mouth or nose — so-called dipping or snuffing.
The Scale of Tobacco Use and the Harms of Smoking and Vaping
Working down from the top of the head to the bottom of the feet, we can say that smoking, vaping, dipping, and snuffing negatively impact every organ and tissue system and cell of the body by virtue of the fact that they all damage the endothelial cells. The endothelial cells are the cells that make up the vasculature, which delivers blood and other nutrients to all the cells and organs and tissues of the body. Those endothelial cells are strongly and negatively impacted by all of the practices I just described.
It has been estimated that cigarettes contain anywhere from 4,000 to 7,000 toxins. The tar in cigarettes — even low-tar cigarettes — as well as the ammonia within cigarettes, the formaldehyde contained within cigarettes, and the carbon monoxide generated from smoking those cigarettes are all carcinogens. For every pack of cigarettes consumed per day, we can reliably estimate a 14-year reduction in lifespan. So cigarettes are literally peeling years off your life.
We can also point to the 50-fold increase in mouth cancers from dipping, and there are nasal cancers as well that are greatly increased by snuffing. And from vaping, we now know based on data that the endothelial cell damage and the direct effects of damage to the lungs — even for people who are vaping, which tends to have lower tars than cigarettes — greatly increase the probability of peripheral vascular disease, heart attack, stroke, and cognitive decline.
You might say: cognitive decline? I thought nicotine increases the likelihood that we can maintain healthy neuronal function and cognitive capacity. However, cigarette smoking and vaping are now known to dramatically decrease cognitive function because one of the key things about the brain is that it is the most metabolically demanding organ — it consumes a lot of glucose, or if you're ketogenic, you need ketones. When blood flow is compromised, you start getting short-term memory lapses and working memory lapses.
Why People Use Nicotine Despite the Risks
What we can very reliably say is that currently more than 1 billion people consume tobacco in order to get their nicotine, because that's really the reinforcing element within tobacco. This may lead you to the question of why in the world would people do this. Well, it turns out most of them don't want to. In the best surveys one can find — asking whether people would quit smoking or vaping if they could — at least 70% of cigarette smokers say they would love to quit. And yet they find that to be exceedingly difficult. The reason they find it exceedingly difficult is because of all the brain neurochemistry we talked about before.
Withdrawal: What Happens When You Stop
If you look at the effects of withdrawal, what you find is that as soon as 4 hours after the last ingestion of nicotine — by way of cigarette, vaping, dipping, or snuffing — people start to experience agitation and craving for nicotine. While craving is a vague concept, it's actually a very specific biological mechanism. It's the drop in dopamine that's starting to occur — so much so that there's a drop in dopamine below baseline. The increase in dopamine that would normally be experienced from smoking, vaping, dipping, or snuffing is now not happening, and in fact the levels of dopamine are dropping below where they would have been even without performing that behavior. That's what craving is. And withdrawal is an increased sense of that craving, as well as a lot of negative effects like stomach aches, nausea, irritability, and often collections of all of those.
I want to highlight one very brief point: nicotine is not the cause of cancer. Nicotine is not the carcinogen. It's the other things in tobacco or associated with the nicotine delivery device that are causing cancer, as well as the other negative impacts on health by way of disrupted endothelial blood vessel function.
Vaping: Why It Is More Addictive Than Cigarettes
That leads us to the issue of vaping. People don't vape tobacco. The way that vaping pens are designed is that they include some liquid, involve heat, and do not involve the burning of tobacco. In a lot of ways, vaping resembles crack cocaine. The reason why vaping and crack cocaine are so similar is the speed of entry of the substance into the bloodstream. Both crack cocaine and vaping cause very rapid increases in the relevant psychoactive substances. In the case of vaping, there's a very rapid increase in blood concentrations of nicotine — much faster than occurs with cigarette smoking or other modes of nicotine delivery.
That speed of onset turns out to be a critical parameter, because the speed of onset of nicotine is going to also determine the speed of release of dopamine in the nucleus accumbens and ventral tegmental area — that mesolimbic reward pathway. With the mesolimbic reward pathway, it's not just about the peak — the maximal amount of dopamine that's released — but the time course, how steep the curve is, how quickly that dopamine increases. That's going to determine how reinforcing, how habit-forming, and indeed how addictive a particular substance is.
So one of the major important differences between vaping and cigarette smoking is that the onset of dopamine release from vaping is faster. Even a subtle increase in the rate at which dopamine increases in the mesolimbic reward pathway can make a given amount of nicotine much more habit-forming and addictive. This probably explains the fact that many more people — in particular young people aged 25 and younger — are vaping at phenomenal rates.
Young people's brains are essentially getting wired to the expectation that dopamine is going to be increased dramatically and quickly, under their control — except it's under their control only in a very narrow set of circumstances. Recall the definition of addiction: a progressive narrowing of the things that bring you pleasure. So it comes as no surprise that vaping is strongly associated with increased levels of depression, especially when vaping use drops off.
The whole system can be recovered by abstinence from nicotine consumption. But the dopamine system is applied to everything — all sense of well-being, all sense of motivation. So that's one of the things that makes vaping in particular so hard to quit. Vaping is actually harder to quit than cigarette smoking for most people.
Quitting: Why It's So Hard and What the Numbers Say
The success rate of quitting smoking when people try to go cold turkey — just quit with no assistance whatsoever, maybe telling their family and friends — is exceedingly low. It's 5%. And of the 5% that succeed in quitting, a full 65% of them relapse within a year. But it's not to say that people cannot quit. In fact, they can. There are a couple of methods that have been shown to help people quit — some behavioral and some pharmacologic.
Clinical Hypnosis: Dr. David Spiegel's Stanford Protocol
I want to touch on the behavioral ones first, because it turns out there's a quite powerful method for quitting nicotine ingestion by way of cigarette smoking — which also carries over to vaping. This is beautiful work done by my colleague and close collaborator at Stanford, Dr. David Spiegel. He is our associate chair of psychiatry, has been a guest on the Huberman Lab podcast, and is a world expert — if not the world expert — in the clinical applications of hypnosis.
Clinical hypnosis is where the patient actually directs their own brain changes toward a specific emotional or behavioral goal. Work from Dr. David Spiegel's laboratory done in 1993, but now repeated many, many times, has carried over into some more modern studies. Those studies have shown that using a specific form of hypnosis, people can achieve complete and total cessation of cigarette smoking. And there's no reason to believe this doesn't also carry over to vaping — through one single hypnosis session.
The success rates are incredibly high when one considers that normally it would be only a 5% success rate. The success rate with this particular hypnosis developed at Stanford School of Medicine by Dr. David Spiegel is 23% of people who do this hypnosis one time succeed in quitting smoking.
Pharmacologic Approaches: Bupropion and Nicotine Replacement Therapy
There are other methods that people have used to successfully quit smoking, vaping, or other forms of nicotine delivery. There's an excellent review article on this topic published in 2020. The title is "Pharmacologic Approach to Smoking Cessation: An Updated Review for Daily Clinical Practice." This review covers all of the options available and steps through nicotine replacement therapy and various compounds, several of which I'm going to talk about now, which have been shown to increase that number from only 5%.
One of the main pharmacologic approaches that has received a lot of attention in recent years is bupropion — sometimes referred to by its commercial name Wellbutrin. Bupropion is a compound that increases the release of dopamine and, to a lesser extent, epinephrine and some other neurochemicals as well. It's used for the treatment of depression and for smoking cessation. I want to really emphasize that there is an increased seizure risk with bupropion. Nonetheless, for people who can take it safely — and again, this is a prescription drug, so a board-certified psychiatrist or other physician is going to have to prescribe it if it's appropriate for you — it moves that number from a 5% success rate to about 20% of people successfully overcoming their smoking or vaping addiction.
It's important to ask why this would work. Bupropion is not increasing nicotine per se. What it's doing is tapping on that mesolimbic reward pathway, increasing dopamine or at least allowing dopamine levels to stay substantially elevated enough that people don't experience the drop in dopamine that leads to the withdrawal symptoms, the lessening of mood, and so on.
A very common approach for people trying to quit smoking or vaping is to use nicotine itself — through a patch, gum, or other delivery device that is not cigarettes or a vape pen — in order to maintain levels of nicotine in their bloodstream, and thereby in their brain and body, to the same extent that they would if they were smoking or vaping. The idea is to maybe gradually take down the total amount of nicotine by reducing the number or size of nicotine gum pieces ingested each day, or keeping the patch on for a shorter amount of time, or getting a lower-dose patch that releases less nicotine overall. All of those approaches have been shown to be reasonably successful.
Staged Nicotine Replacement: Why Rotating Methods Works Best
It turns out that a combination of approaches is best. It was very clear from the literature that using nicotine patches for some period of time and then switching to a gum and then perhaps switching to a nasal spray is going to be the most effective approach. The question is how long to continue each of those and whether or not to overlap them. Doing one for about a week and then switching to another for about a week and then switching to another is one rational and reasonable approach that many people have used successfully.
The transdermal patches provide a fairly steady-state dopamine release across the day, and oftentimes people are wearing them at night as well. So a nicotine patch is going to be very effective for a week or so. But then switching to a nasal spray or switching to nicotine gum for about a week — which is going to change the kinetics of that nicotine absorption into the bloodstream and change the release of dopamine and other neurochemicals within the brain — is going to keep the system intentionally off-balance so that it never comes to expect one single pattern or amplitude of dopamine release.
The body and brain seek homeostasis. So if there's a big increase in all those things like blood pressure and mood, typically your baseline will drop a little to compensate for that over time after a couple of days or even weeks of ingesting nicotine. The day that you quit, that homeostatic mechanism in your brain and body — which sets your level of mood and arousal — does not know and hasn't adjusted to the fact that you're not bringing in nicotine anymore. So what ends up happening is that baseline, which has been adjusted down to offset the increases in mood and alertness when you smoke or vape, is lower than it normally would be.
The Critical First Week of Quitting
That's not much help to anyone who's already started smoking or vaping. But it's very important to understand that the reason why relapse rates are so high within the first week — 75% of people relapse within one week, and overall failure rates are 95% — is because people don't expect to feel even worse than they did prior to ever smoking or vaping.
So that first week is absolutely critical. And the beauty of understanding this is that if you can get through that first week — either by sheer grit or by finding other methods to increase dopamine through healthy means — chances are quite a bit higher that you'll be able to maintain cessation of smoking or vaping. Cold showers and ice baths have been shown to increase dopamine. Exercise and positive social interactions are also very likely to help people offset that reduction in dopamine if they are to get through that first week.
Hypnosis and things like bupropion can also assist in that. However, I did consult with Dr. David Spiegel in anticipation of this episode, and regardless of the method used to quit smoking, vaping, snuffing, or dipping, there's good evidence that a routine — maybe once a month or even once a week — hypnosis-type approach to replenish or even enhance the neural circuits that are allowing you to stay away from nicotine is going to be a very good idea.
Alcohol and Relapse Risk
Just a very brief mention: there is a vast literature on the fact that when people have quit smoking or vaping or other forms of consuming nicotine, consuming alcohol greatly increases the probability of relapse.
Conclusion: Nicotine in Perspective
I want to reemphasize that nicotine is not what causes cancer. It is the delivery device that causes cancer and the other negative health effects. That is not to say that people should be ingesting nicotine through any different methods simply to get a cognitive boost.
Nicotine, it should now be clear, is an immensely powerful substance — one of the most commonly ingested substances on the face of the earth, and has been for a very long time. Now that you understand the underlying biology and the way in which it changes your psychology and physiology, that should come as no surprise.