Andrew Huberman interviews developmental neuroscientist Dr Mary Helen Immordino Yang on emotions, learning, and education
Andrew Huberman speaks with Dr Mary Helen Immordino Yang about how emotions and social experience shape learning, consciousness, and human development.
Summary
Andrew Huberman interviews Dr Mary Helen Immordino Yang, a developmental neuroscientist whose work sits at the intersection of neurobiology, emotion, and education. Drawing on her collaboration with Antonio Damasio, she argues that the brain is fundamentally an organ of the body — not separate from it — and that consciousness itself emerges from the brain's mapping of bodily states. She contends that high-level emotional experiences like awe and inspiration are not separate from basic survival biology but are in fact deeply rooted in it. A central claim of the conversation is that emotion is not a distraction from learning but its very engine: what we feel about is what we think about, and what we think about is what we learn. She argues that the Western education system has systematically misdirected students' emotions toward performance outcomes rather than ideas, stunting intellectual development precisely at the adolescent stage when the brain is most primed for deep meaning-making. She also connects the neuroscience of narrative and empathy to broader social phenomena, including dehumanization and political polarization.
Key Takeaways
FULL TRANSCRIPT
The relationship between high-level emotions and basic biology
Andrew Huberman: I've heard you talk before about inspiration and awe. Inspiration and awe seem to me like rather high-level emotional experiences compared to, say, fear or happiness. What is the role of inspiration, awe, and story in how we learn and experience life, starting at a young age?
Dr Mary Helen Immordino Yang: I think what you've noticed is actually fundamental to the conundrum of being human — that our most high-level, complex brain states and mind states are also fundamentally hooking themselves into the most basic biological machinery that keeps us alive. Our beliefs, our experiences, our interpretations of the meaning of things — and that's where the story comes in. The stories that we conjure collectively with other people, culturally in spaces, inside our own selves — those stories become a kind of through line that organizes the way in which we construct our own experience, consciousness even, I would say. When we hook into those very basic survival systems by recruiting them into these narratives about the nature of reality and the power of the meaning we make, what happens is we get this amazingly both fundamental and high-level state simultaneously where we feel expansive. We feel like it's all so incredibly beautiful, and we are, I would argue, actually ramping into or catching into the very basic survival mechanisms that make us conscious, that make us alive. And that is in essence the power of being human. That's the power of our intelligence at this late stage in our evolution.
The brain as an organ of the body
Andrew Huberman: I've heard you say before — and I love this, and I want to make sure you get attribution for it, not me — that we basically have a brain to control our body. Could you comment on this notion of the brain being the organ responsible for controlling the body, and what that dialogue is like?
Dr Mary Helen Immordino Yang: The first thing I'll say is that I learned that idea from working with Antonio Damasio. He taught me that it's the feeling of the body — an organism's ability to represent or map the state of the interior and exterior of the body — that becomes the substrate for consciousness and for the mind. The work that I've been doing is basically addressing exactly the question you're asking: how is it that we construct a narrative, construct a conscious feeling into something that feels like a narrative, that feels like a belief state or an emotion state or an experience? And what is the role of embodiment in that? What is the role of the brain in that? And what also is the role of culture and cultural context and other people in that? Because what we're really learning across the sciences right now is just how incredibly social and interdependent our species is. Our biology is inherently a social one. We are directly dependent on other people for the formulation of our own sense of self. We interact with one another and co-construct a sense of self and a sense of meaning via those cultural spaces and those nuanced ways of accommodating each other mentally and physically that lead to the feeling of us.
So back to your original question: what's very clear is that the kind of background sense of the body, the mapping and the regulation of the body, is a basic substrate — a kind of trampoline for the mind. We are managing our survival. We now have lots of evidence from across many kinds of science about the interdependence of our stress and social relationships and our immunity and our ability to digest food. And it's even now very clear that it's not even just us — there's a whole microbiome and all kinds of other organisms that are assisting us and collaborating with us in that.
The brain is a specialized organ of the body. In fact, it's not a separate thing. It's an outgrowth or an elaboration of that process — a specialization of it, a localization of it in a way that provides enough processing power to really construct all kinds of feelings and mental states and beliefs and imaginings out of basically just the feeling of being here. And then the amazing part is that our brain is also imposing those back down onto our body. So the way in which our body reacts and is modulated in response to mental states is also very real. We have a kind of dynamic conversation happening — brain and body and mind co-conjuring one another in real time. And that leads to all kinds of dynamic possibility spaces for how we are and how we feel as we grow through time. As humans, the legacy of our intelligence is to tap into those possibility spaces and start to construct them into meaningful chains of ideas, chains of experiences over time that we call story.
How emotional development unfolds across childhood
Andrew Huberman: I'm fascinated by the idea that early in life we experience some interaction with the world — it could be with other people, it could be with an object — and it makes us feel something powerful, and that lays a template of recognition. Meaning that later in life, and perhaps throughout life, we're always consciously or subconsciously going back to trying to experience that same kind of awe or inspiration. So is what we're learning across the lifespan a recognition of feelings in our body, or is it cognitive, or both?
Dr Mary Helen Immordino Yang: It's a dynamic emergence. Let me give you an example I use sometimes to help myself understand the notion. My little daughter, Nora, when she was two — I was sitting in the kitchen one day drinking a cup of tea. I was sad about something that had happened in my life, but I wasn't weeping or anything. I was just sitting there, kind of lost in my own thoughts. She was playing around on the floor. She came over and noticed I wasn't really there with her. My arm was hanging down. She picked up my arm and held it against her face and said, "Don't worry, mama. I'll take care of you." And I said, "Oh, Nora, that's so sweet, sweetie. I'll take care of you too." And she said, "And mama, I really love you." And then she said, "I mean, I really love your arm. I really love your arm."
Fast forward two years later — almost exactly two years — she's four and a couple of months, and she was in bed one night, lying in her bed in the dark. I walked by and listened at the door to see if she was asleep. And I hear this little whisper come out: "Mama, I love you more than I'm glad that there's daytime."
What's changed developmentally from her at age two to her at age four? I would argue that the physiological substrate of her attachment to her mother is probably quite similar. She had this visceral, automatic, biological attachment connection to me emotionally that she was trying to leverage in the service of making sense of the world and adapting herself to the situation — helping me, in the first case. But what's changed remarkably is not the substrate of that attachment. It's her ability to conceptualize it. When she's two, her love is experienced as this incredibly concrete, embodied, real physical thing — I love you, I mean, I really love the body part I am currently smooshing against my face. Whereas two years later, she can conceptualize that love in terms of an idea: wouldn't it be awful if there was nighttime all the time and there was no sunshine and daylight and I couldn't go out to play? She's thinking about how much she is grateful for there to be sunlight, and in her little mind she connected that to the feeling of being attached to me and used one to explain the other. So both things now have meaning. And that is the way that we start to elaborate these very basic physiological attachment states, aversion states, motivational states of various sorts into mental states, beliefs, poems, love songs — all the things that even between age two and age four are really mental elaborations, meaning-making of that very physiologically basic sensation.
Andrew Huberman: So the contact with your arm was the life example she was using as a two-year-old that maps to an internal feeling. So the question is: is what we are doing across the lifespan recognizing basic emotional states — which are not infinite but can each exist along a continuum — a little bit of love to completely in love, a little angry and annoyed to completely furious? Are we talking about maybe ten to thirty core emotions that we are simply binning our experiences into and mapping onto, and then that's our life story?
Dr Mary Helen Immordino Yang: I think yes. There are an awful lot of basic physiological mechanisms that become motivational mechanisms — adaptive mechanisms — that we share with all life forms. What we basically are doing is taking these very primitive physiological regulatory capacities that are essentially there to keep you alive and conjuring out of them a form of consciousness, an awareness of those processes that becomes something that feels mentally powerful to us. And then we start to build more and more facility, more and more wisdom around conjuring the story that makes the most direct, parsimonious sense out of the things that you imagine somebody else may have experienced given the complexities of the context in which they find themselves. It becomes more and more dynamic, more and more inferential.
This also goes back to what you were saying about development. My little two-year-old loves the arm. Then she loves me as much as something else she really appreciates, like daylight. And then she goes on from there. When she's eighty, God willing someday, she'll be making a different kind of story, picking out things that matter in more subtle ways that other people may not notice — because of the historical context, because of the more lived experience she brings to that story. So the things that become salient, the things you learn how to notice and build a story out of, are developmental and learned across time. But the basic fundamental processes around the emotions are always driving the need to make the story.
How culture shapes perception and narrative
Dr Mary Helen Immordino Yang: When we are perceiving things — either very basic things like a visual scene or hugely complex elaborate things like Martin Luther King's speech — we are as much imposing onto the world our own expectations of what is there as we are perceiving what's actually there. As we impose onto the world, we bring what you might call our cultural ways of seeing and knowing, our values and beliefs, and we push them onto the experience of what we notice. Even in very basic ways, cultural values change the way in which people observe and remember scenes.
There's classic work by Shinobu Kitayama and others showing that in Japan versus in the US, when you show people a scene — say, an underwater scene with rocks and plants and little fish swimming by and then one big fish swimming by — and you ask a Japanese person what this is a picture of, they tend to say it's a scene of rocks and plants and little fish and then a big fish swims by. If you ask a Western-educated American person, they say, "Oh, it's a fish swimming through a scene." He's shown that this is very, very automatic — it's very low-level, it's perceptual, not just conceptual, and it actually changes what people notice in the scene and what they remember later.
We learn how to filter input. We're not little robots or video cameras walking around observing the world. When we see something as complex as a social story, we impose onto that all kinds of personal experiences. So what we're really doing is moving through the world not in a receptive, passive way — we are actively imposing ourselves onto the world, actively bringing our interpretive power and adapting what we do next relative to the way in which we accommodate or assimilate things that may disagree with our schema or may align with and reinforce it. Piaget talked about this a hundred years ago.
This matters a lot for the ways that humans experience the world more broadly. Think about a terrible topic like genocide or the Holocaust. How does something like that happen? How is it that people who have empathy, who love their family, who love their neighbors, can suddenly turn on each other? What's happened is they've shifted the way in which they narratize the context of those events. The way in which they impose interpretation on somebody else's pain has been fundamentally shifted from "that's another human suffering" to "that's not a human — that's a rat, a pig, a bug." That dehumanization process allows us to shift our story set so that we bring another set of values and beliefs into the space.
Andrew Huberman: I'm glad you brought up this example, because I think for a lot of people it's inconceivable. But I've never heard it framed the way you're describing it — that if the story becomes not about the other person's suffering but primarily about one's own story of suffering, that can suppress or literally inhibit the neural circuits that invoke empathy. Then it makes perfectly good neurobiological sense as to why that would at least be possible. I don't think it's a good thing — it's just like many aspects of our biology and psychology, it just happens to be the way things are.
Dr Mary Helen Immordino Yang: It is. And I think the only hope we have to protect ourselves against these possibilities is to systematically develop dispositions in ourselves — proclivities within ourselves — to question our own motives, and to deconstruct our own assumptions about situations and engage with other people's perspectives systematically. When we develop those dispositions, the hope is that we are developing within ourselves a kind of veto system — a system for checking our own motivations against other people's experiences of those motivations.
So much of what's leading us into these very divisive political times — the rise of authoritarianism not just in the US but around many places in the world, all of which by the way are Western-educated — is that we are taught that to know something means you own something in yourself and then you take that with you and impose it on the world forevermore. I know how to do algebra and I can do it whenever you ask me — that's what a good student is. Whereas when people learn to engage with their own knowledge states in more curious, open-minded, flexible ways, they dispositionally teach themselves to check their assumptions, to rethink what they think they know. And this is key developmentally — to notice when we need to do that and when we should just plow ahead and it's totally fine.
What we're doing right now to ourselves, both in the education system and in things like social media, is reinforcing our own biases by diving down rabbit holes where we rehear the same thing over and over again that reinforces our own belief systems. And then we come to believe those things, and those put us on a train toward a particular kind of action or belief system that never becomes deconstructed. It's very comfortable and easy to do. But the responsibility we have as individuals and as groups — as humans, given the amazing intelligence we have — is to rise above that and actually look back on our own selves reflectively, deconstruct our preferences, deconstruct our values and beliefs, and systematically query them, specifically around how they impact or influence or change the situations of those around us, or don't — the situations and sustainability of the world that supports us, or don't.
So it all comes back to the emotions that drive our thinking. We have these very basic primitive physiological states which vary across individuals — the degree to which they are incredibly powerful and easily evoked versus not. There's a lot of range in that, and all of that variation makes things interesting. It's our ability to learn to experience those and to develop wisdom around when we need to query our own emotions and deconstruct the narratives we're using to validate or substantiate those emotions — in order to assess whether we actually are right, whether we should continue, or whether we should step back and reframe.
That kind of mental flexibility really comes out of an emotional disposition. It is our ability — and this takes it back to what you were asking at the very beginning — to not just drive from what feels like the bottom up, which of course is always starting in the top down because you've got some interpretation of the world that makes you feel fear, that makes your body react, but also to be able to rise above, to transcend, and think about what are the broader systemic, historical, ethical, civic implications of this narrative I'm telling myself, which feels by default like the truth. How might I deconstruct those systematically? How might I invite others to give me their version of those events and engage with those systematically in order to really appreciate the implications of my beliefs?
So the bottom line is that the emotions we're talking about today are actually the fundamental drivers of all of our thinking, decision-making, relationship building, our community lives, and our personal well-being — all in one mix. But that doesn't excuse us for acting on their bequest. It actually imbues us with a responsibility to develop dispositions to systematically query those and reframe them when they are not serving us or the world well.
Redesigning education around emotional engagement and meaning-making
Andrew Huberman: What do you think can be done at a concrete level — in terms of education of younger people as well as people who are out of high school and beyond — to try and adopt these more encompassing modes of learning and experiencing the world?
Dr Mary Helen Immordino Yang: I think one really important step that as a society we will have to take — or we won't make it, and I know that sounds a little dramatic, but I actually think it's true — is that we need to get brave about how we think about the process of educating our young people and what it actually means to expose young people to developmentally appropriate opportunities to grow themselves as thinkers, as individuals, and as civic agents and community members.
Our Western-designed education system has in it some very basic beliefs about what counts as knowing, what is worth thinking about and knowing about, and how do I test you on that — beliefs that I think are deeply problematic and lead us to a place where we are actively discouraged from really playing with ideas, engaging systematically with our own beliefs, deconstructing those beliefs, and engaging with complex perspectives on topics and ideas. That is just not what school is about, and it needs to be.
The way in which we think about school is basically judged by "learning outcomes." What have you learned? And how do we know that? We make you demonstrate it by yourself, under time pressure, in a particular setting. Or you're going to come back and I'm going to give you a question and you're going to give me the answer I had in mind, and if you do that in time, I'll say you learned it and now we're done.
As compared to a system — and there are educational systems like this — for example, the Performance Assessment Consortium in New York City, which is a consortium of public schools. They have a dispensation from the New York State government not to give the Regents exam as their graduation requirement. Instead, they have alternative ways of assessing kids where students work for months to years, depending on the project, on these in-depth intellectual, multidisciplinary projects. They explore a topic, they engage with their own process of learning about that topic, they bring in teachers and community experts and other people, they present their work, and then they query the work and talk about their own learning process and what could happen next and what decisions they made.
Andrew Huberman: It's like a graduate thesis.
Dr Mary Helen Immordino Yang: Exactly. You have to invent not just the work but the question. You need to look at the world and notice what it is we're not understanding that we would benefit from understanding, and find a way to isolate and systematically query that. Why don't we build education systems from preschool all the way up that engage people systematically in that kind of intellectual curiosity?
We know that in little kids' education — preschool education — if you don't have the water table and the sand table and the cool stuff and the choices and the ways to engage with each other, all the stuff that's really age-appropriate for three-year-olds to touch and smush and try to taste and whatever else, they're going to be a mess on the floor. They're just not going to come. They're going to refuse to come to school, laying in the doorway throwing temper tantrums. So we know how to do little kid education. It doesn't mean we always do it, but we know that they need to be intrigued. They need to be invited to think, and they bring their natural curiosity, and then you expand the range of ways they can leverage that curiosity to discover new things they hadn't known to think about before.
Then we get to the standard educational system and we somehow think that that natural human proclivity to engage curiously and meaningfully with deep thinking about ideas and the world is inefficient and inappropriate and frightening. And we teach kids: no, no, no, turn that off. It's dangerous. If you do it, it's considered insubordinate. What we want you to do instead is just let me give you what I've already figured out for you. I'm going to give it to you and you are going to give it back to me.
Andrew Huberman: I think what you're describing is so key. I never thought about it from the perspective that as young kids we're given all the things that are going to drive our sensory world in the appropriate ways — touch and sound and vision — trying to build meaning in our minds, and that we get to, as very young learners, impose some of our own intrinsic motivation to do certain things and not others, and that that isn't supported as we grow older. What age do you think this falls off? And also, how do we address the issue that there are certain basic skills that not everyone is going to perform well at? For the kid who says "I don't like math" — well, you still have to learn it. How do you conjure up a joy or an appreciation in that kid? It sounds like the emotion system is the key system to leverage in order to learn. Could you talk about the relationship between emotion and learning, because I realize this is really the center of what you do?
Emotion as the engine of learning
Dr Mary Helen Immordino Yang: You could say it this way: whatever you're having emotion about is what you're thinking about. And whatever you're thinking about, you could hope to learn about. So if the emotions are about the outcomes — did I get it right? Am I going to flunk? Did I get an A+? I'm so smart, I'm so stupid — if those are the main drivers, then that is what you're learning about. If the emotions are about the actual ideas in play — the math, the physics, the why does the ball roll down the ramp, wait a minute, that's the same as why the moon goes around — when the emotions are about ideas, then what you're engaging with is learning about ideas.
What I would argue is that in setting up the kind of accountability system we have, we have taught people that their emotion should be about these high-stakes accountability measures, which means that's what we're learning how to think about.
Andrew Huberman: Perform.
Dr Mary Helen Immordino Yang: Perform — not how to think about the ideas, not the intrinsic power of using math to understand the world in a different way. So how do you engage kids? You engage kids by setting out rich problem spaces, problems that invite them to try to engage with something that piques their curiosity, that's meaningful to them. Or with a kid who really hates it — what is it that you do find interesting? Start there, and start using your academic skills in a way that will give you power to do what it is you're interested in doing. That's the way in. Use your writing, use your math, use your persuasive argument skills, use your filmmaking skills, whatever it is, to tell the story of something that you find deeply, meaningfully powerful to understand.
We've got the cart before the horse. I'm not saying you don't have to learn math or you don't have to learn to read or write or do all these other kinds of skills. But we make those the metric of the education system and the aim of it, when in fact it's the quality of the horse — can that horse pull the thing? That's the development of the person. What they put in their cart then serves that development. It's the toolkit of ways of knowing and understanding that come with you as you move into the world.
But this takes real developmental skill on the part of educators who are not supported, resourced, or trained to think about development in these ways. You asked when does this fall off? It really depends on what school system you are in and what demographic you are in. But for almost everybody except for the privileged few who are in very progressive alternative schools, it falls off by adolescence — which is when school gets serious. And it's also, ironically, when developmentally kids are developing the neural capacity, the psychosocial capacity, and the drive to infer complex narrative meaning from the things they are doing. You know, these aren't just my shoes — these are a statement about what I believe about sustainability and about sports and about adults and counterculture. As we grow into a space where we're driven to challenge and think about big meanings and engage with perspectives and emotions and social issues and broad important existential questions — be they in physics or in art or in the social civic domain — what do we do? We double down on controlling the input and the output transactional mechanisms that count as academic rigor and achievement. We start to ask kids, you know, what's the name of the servant who shows up in the scene in Great Expectations — is it Molly or is it Maria? And that is not the point of reading Great Expectations.
We take away — because we're afraid as educators, as a society — we've got this narrative around young people's propensity to build and construct meaning in these spaces and to construct self in these spaces. That agency frightens us because we're worried they're going to take risks, they're going to do something stupid, they're going to fall off the track, they're going to not make it in the traditional system. And in trying to protect them and shield them from their own curiosities, their own dispositions for meaning-making, we actually stunt their ability to grow themselves.
What we're really doing is producing people who are gutted of their own inner drive to become someone who thinks powerfully in the space of the world. We are frightened to let our young people have that power. The role of adults is to wrap around young people and help them learn to be reflective, to be systematic, to be rigorous with themselves as they develop the capacities and dispositions to deconstruct their own beliefs, to deconstruct their own aims and goals and the ways they understand the world, and to rebuild them iteratively over and over in this intellectually humble, curious way — where we're constantly querying ourselves, constantly querying other people, where we're willing to sit with uncertainty in complex problem spaces and think through the possibilities rather than settle quickly onto one solution.
What does school expect you to do? Settle immediately onto one solution — which, by the way, is the solution I already had in mind when I gave you the question. As compared to sitting with young people and allowing them, in safe and appropriate ways, the space in which to actually grapple with complex, powerful questions. When kids develop the proclivities to do that, they learn how to manage those very human capacities that we've been talking about the whole time. They learn to appreciate and manage those capacities within their own selves.
Andrew Huberman: You're remarkable, and I really mean that. I feel like we could go on forever exploring these ideas. It's one of the things I love so much about your work — it's really nested in real-world applications. Your thoughts and perspectives on education and how it could be better, at the level of educating kids at home, teaching ourselves, teachers, and the education system — I hope they will ring far and wide, because they really can be implemented. We're not talking about the need to purchase a bunch of stuff.
Dr Mary Helen Immordino Yang: No. We need to start with a different disposition. We need to start with a different goal. Learning is not the goal, it's not the outcome. The goal needs to be the development of the person. How is a person changing themselves having learned this? And then you design the learning opportunities to change who people are capable of becoming. So the learning is there, but it's not the end point. It's just the means to something else which we haven't been attending to enough — and that's the development of the person, who they become having learned that.
Andrew Huberman: Beautifully put. Thank you so much for your time, and thank you so much for the work you do. I can't wait to have another discussion with you about the emerging research.
Dr Mary Helen Immordino Yang: Great. I'll be back.