Sermon on Mark 2:18–3:6: Why Jesus and Religion Are Opposed
A sermon by James de Costobadie (Costa), Senior Pastor at Latimer Church, on the contrast between Christianity and human religion, drawn from Mark 2:18–3:6.
Summary
James de Costobadie (Costa) preaches through Mark 2:18–3:6, arguing that Jesus's greatest enemies were not atheists or agnostics but devoutly religious people — and that this is no accident. The passage presents two episodes of conflict between Jesus and the Pharisees, one over fasting and one over Sabbath observance, which Costa uses to draw out two central contrasts: Christianity is a feast, not a fast, and Christianity offers a saviour, not a system. Costa argues that religion, by its nature, places rules and systems at the centre, whereas Jesus comes as a bridegroom — to restore humanity to a personal relationship with God. The sermon closes with a challenge to Christians to examine whether they exhibit genuine joy in Christ or have drifted into going through the motions, and with a call to pray for softened hearts — both for themselves and for those around them.
Key Takeaways
FULL TRANSCRIPT
Introduction: "I'm Not Religious"
I've been a Christian nearly 35 years, and over that time I've heard many reasons why people don't or won't become Christians — what it is that puts them off. One of the most common over that period has been simply people saying, "Well, I'm not religious. I'm not a religious sort of person." In fact, that may have actually become more common as a reason, because going back some years and a few decades, religion was perhaps seen as a force for good in our culture, whereas these days it's much more likely to be seen as a force for bad. Religion has caused so many problems around the world, and so for many people, not only are they not religious themselves, but they really don't want to be associated with anything religious. And so they don't want to look into the person of Jesus.
If only they had read what Jesus says about religion. Maybe it's one of the more surprising aspects of the Bible — what Jesus says about religion — that Jesus's greatest enemies when he lived on earth were not atheists or agnostics, but devoutly religious people. And if the world is critical of religion, Jesus was much, much more critical.
Our passage this morning helps us to understand why it is that Jesus and religion are so opposed. One offers rules for us to try to climb to God — in other words, puts ourselves back at the centre. The other tells a story, a love story, of a God who in compassion and love has come to us, to restore us back to himself in relationship.
If we're here this morning and we're not yet a Christian, I hope it will help us to see how Jesus is so different — so very different — to human religion. And for those who are Christians, we may be challenged as to whether we currently have and exhibit the joy in Christ that should be ours when we believe in Jesus. Or perhaps it challenges us as to whether we've begun to just go through the motions, like religious people go through the motions.
The passage today shows us two things that religion gets wrong.
Christianity Is a Feast, Not a Fast
First of all, Christianity is a feast, not a fast. Religion thinks it's a fast. Jesus says it's a feast.
The issue that triggers the conflict in that first episode is the question that comes in verse 18. Have a look down. Now John's disciples and the Pharisees were fasting, and some people came and asked him, "How is it that John's disciples and the disciples of the Pharisees are fasting, but yours are not?" And Jesus answered, "How can the guests of the bridegroom fast while he is with them?"
The Old Testament commanded fasting, but only once a year. Once a year the nation of Israel was to fast on the Day of Atonement. They were to mourn for their sins and they were to remember how God had provided for their sins to be taken away. They had this goat, and the sins of the nation would be laid on the goat, and the goat was to wander off into the desert. Later on in Israel's history, particularly around the time of the exile, fasting became more common — much more common — as the nation saw their sins, which had caused them to be driven out from the land. Fasting was really a sign of penitence, crying out to God to have mercy upon them.
But as with so many traditions that begin with a good reason, the fasting simply became more and more baked into the lives of people. It became a habit, and over a period of time, a rather meaningless habit. It was simply a thing to be done. To be a faithful Jew was to fast. By the time of Jesus, if you wanted to be anyone as a Jew, fasting on Mondays and Thursdays was the minimum that was laid down.
And so the people who come up to Jesus want to know: why is everyone else fasting and your disciples not? To which Jesus says in verse 19, "How can the guests of the bridegroom fast while he is with them?" The point of fasting was for people to mourn for their sins, to cry out to God to come to save them. But now the Saviour is here. It's no longer a time to fast, says Jesus. It is a time to feast. It's a time to rejoice.
A little while ago I heard a rather cute story of a little girl, aged two or three I think, whose parents took her into a retirement home to meet their elderly relative. Of course, everyone made a great fuss over this little girl, and she loved being there, loved being at the centre of attention, and they had a great time. Anyway, they went home. Then sometime later, a few months later, they went back to visit the same relative. She remembered the retirement home and remembered how everyone had loved seeing her there. So she burst into the lounge area and said, "I'm here! I'm here!" And of course, people made a fuss of her again.
Well, Jesus says, "I'm here. I'm here." The Saviour is here. You've been waiting for a saviour from your sins. I'm here. This is no time for fasting. This is a time for feasting.
The Bridegroom Has Come
It's very striking that he uses the picture of a bridegroom. "How can the guests of the bridegroom fast while he is with them?" Because Jesus had not only come into this world to save people from their sins, but to restore us to a relationship — a relationship with the living God, the ultimate relationship for which you and I were made. The relationship to which every human marriage is just a pointer, just a model. Here is the ultimate relationship between humanity and God.
It's an amazing truth that Jesus is alluding to here. In the face of our rejection of God, how does God respond to us? Not as a warrior to come and fight us. Not as a judge to come and condemn us. But as a bridegroom — to come to marry us, that is, to bring us back to himself. And Jesus says that day has come. The bridegroom is here.
In our culture, of course, when it comes to weddings, you wait for the bride. As a minister, I've married a lot of people, and I feel I've spent a reasonable proportion of my life waiting for brides. Twenty-eight minutes was my record, reassuring the groom at the front: "Don't worry, this is entirely normal. I'm sure she'll be here in a moment" — thinking, I'm pretty sure she's ditched him. But anyway, she did turn up. In that culture, they waited for the groom. And when the groom came, celebration was the order of the day. "Well, I am that groom for humanity," says Jesus. "So celebrate."
And the wonderful thing about this is that Jesus has not just come for the mass of humanity, but he's come for individuals — those whom God had chosen before the beginning of the world, that he's always had in mind. He's come for us. Come for you, to take you to be his bride.
There are many people who never have that experience in their life on earth. No one's ever said to them, "You're the one for me." And maybe they're wondering: is it something about me that puts people off? Is it the way I look, or the way I act socially? Or is there something in my past that puts people off? Well, the incredible truth here is that although God knows everything about us — our worst secrets, the skeletons in every cupboard — none of that puts him off. He wanted to come for us, to claim us for himself. He says to us, "You're the one for me." Such a wonderful truth, that we would be so loved, no matter how we've lived in this world, no matter what we've done in life. That's the love that God has for us.
And here is the best bridegroom there will ever be. There is no one to whom he says, "I'm not interested in you." To each person he offers a personal relationship, a marriage relationship. But unlike any normal human marriage — which, as we say in the marriage service, "till death us do part" — will come to an end, this relationship begins in this life and then carries on through death into eternity. And the point is, it's to be celebrated. We should rejoice at that relationship with Jesus.
Much as, if you're married, hopefully around the time you got married and those milestones at the time, there was a certain amount of celebration, of rejoicing that went on. I hope it's not the case that when you got engaged, one of you said, "Well, I don't know, should we get a glass of water to celebrate? A bit of dry biscuit?" No, no, no. Now's the time for a proper celebration.
That's what happened with Teresa and me. I had it all planned out. I took her out to a play — Phantom of the Opera, the musical. And then we went out for a walk, absolutely wonderful. Popped the question. She said yes. And we celebrated. The celebration didn't last long, because then I got back to my flat where I'd been living and explained to my friend what had happened. He said, "You did what? The Phantom of the Opera — isn't that the play about a hideously ugly man who falls in love with a beautiful woman?" Enough on that. So the celebration didn't last long, but a celebration nonetheless.
A Time for Fasting Will Come
Now Jesus said, now is the time for feasting, but there will come a time for fasting. You're not wrong in that, he says. Verse 20: "But the time will come when the bridegroom will be taken from them, and on that day they will fast."
Jesus here is looking ahead to his arrest and his crucifixion. That would be the time for fasting — a time of overwhelming sorrow and mourning for their sins that would take him to the cross. And in terms of where we are today, the story carries on even beyond that. Jesus did die for our sins, and it's right that we should mourn for them. Then, as we know, three days later he was raised from the dead. And we believe in a living Saviour who is with us by his Spirit at every moment of every day. And that's why rejoicing is to be the theme of our lives.
Sure enough, because we live in a fallen world, it will be a mixed experience, and it's right that we should have sadness. We'll have sadness alongside the rejoicing — like human marriages, hopefully there's some rejoicing and joy, but there are sadnesses as well that take place in marriage. And that's true of all of our lives. And because of that, our fallen hearts mean that occasional fasting can actually be a really good thing. Fasting from food occasionally can help us hunger for God, because we're not naturally like that, so it can be a help. Fasting from technology can help us focus on God. I don't know if you've ever sat down and said, "Right, I'll pray for ten minutes," and you can't even get through ten minutes without looking at your phone. And we know it's pathetic. I'm pathetic. I hate myself for doing it. So a fast from technology can help us actually focus on God. An occasional fast can do us good.
But predominantly, we should be people who feast, not fast — who rejoice at all we have in Christ. And we should be known as people of joy. I wonder if that would be true of you. When you go into the workplace, is that how people think of you — as a joyful sort of person? With Christmas and all the stresses that get involved in that, if you mix with wider family, is that how your wider family would see you — as a joyful person? Or are we the ones who introduce tension into every situation?
It's certainly not how people would think of religion, because religion sucks the joy out of anything. We should be different to that — not religious lovers of religion, but lovers of Jesus. And in church, people should feel free to express that in the way that they want. I'd hate the thought that people thought, "I know, I couldn't be like that at Latimer. It's not the way things are done here." No. People should be free to express the joy in the way that they want to do so.
New Cloth, New Wineskins
Jesus brings that joy. And it's Jesus who makes the difference. That's really the point of those last two pictures — the two metaphors Jesus puts one after the other. Verse 21: "No one sews a patch of unshrunk cloth on an old garment. If he does, the new piece will pull away from the old, making the tear worse. And no one pours new wine into old wineskins. If he does, the wine will burst the skins, and both the wine and the wineskins will be ruined. No, he pours new wine into new wineskins."
Two pictures, making the same point: it's Jesus who makes the difference. In fact, who makes all the difference. So just adding Jesus onto a bit of Old Testament religion really doesn't work. It's a bit like putting a new patch of cloth on an old garment — back in the day, if that new patch was untreated, when it gets wet it'll shrink, and then it'll end up pulling the garment and making the tear worse. Or new wine going into old wineskins — old wineskins become hard. You put new wine that's still fermenting into this thing, the wine is bubbling away, but the wineskins can't expand, and eventually they pop, and the wine's all over the ground and the wineskins are ruined anyway.
You can't just add Jesus onto a bit of Old Testament religion as if he made no difference. And we might note for ourselves: you cannot just add Jesus onto life as if he just sort of makes up the surplus. "I'm basically all right eighty, ninety percent of the time. I'll just add a bit of Jesus. I think Jesus would help me in life." No, no, no. That doesn't work. You cannot just add Jesus, because it's Jesus who actually makes the difference. It's Jesus who fulfilled all of the Old Testament. It's Jesus to whom we should bow. He makes the difference in our lives if we fully submit to him.
These religious people needed to know that, and so do we. In other words, we're not to shrink back into a bit of religion. There are always some people who are attracted by visible religion, which seems to offer more comfort and more security, that appeals to our desire for history, maybe feels more authentic. I remember someone saying to me at Latimer, "It's very simple at the front" — I think they were expecting more colours, more clothes, more something on the walls, whatever. Very simple at the front. But really there is a reason for that. We live by faith in the Son of God who died for us. We're to focus our eyes and our hearts on him, that we might find our satisfaction in him and live by faith in him and rejoice in who he is and everything that he has given to us.
And by the same token, we mustn't go through the motions in the Christian life. Jesus has changed the whole course of history. We should be in awe of him. He died to set us free from our sins and from the fear of death. He rose to give us life, to give us peace with God, to give us concrete hope for the future, to give us an everlasting joy. It's Jesus who makes the difference. To be a Christian is to enjoy a feast, not a fast, and we should rejoice in him.
Christianity Is a Saviour, Not a System
Which then links to the second half of this passage and these other two incidents, which you'll notice are linked by the fact they both took place on the Sabbath. And they teach us the second thing that's wrong with religion. Christianity is a feast, not a fast. Christianity is also a saviour, not a system.
We're told in verse 23 — have a look down — that one Sabbath Jesus was going through the grain fields, and as his disciples walked along, they began to pick some heads of grain. And the Pharisees said to them, "Look, why are they doing what is unlawful on the Sabbath?"
So here's a Sabbath. They've been in the synagogue. The sermon probably went on a bit too long as usual. They didn't have any food with them. They're on the way home. And as they walk back through the grain field, the disciples are hungry, and so they pick some ears of corn. And this immediately attracts the attention of the Pharisees.
The Pharisees were very hot on the law of God. They were aware that everyone falls short. They knew the law, and to them it was obvious: the more you follow the law and take God seriously, the more likely it is that he will come quicker and rescue his people and usher in his kingdom. So yes, the Old Testament said keep the Sabbath — but what does that mean? Well, says the Pharisees, what we'd better do is make it crystal clear with some more rules, to help people know what it means to keep the Sabbath. And so this whole extra body of laws comes in. Eventually it was codified into what's called the Mishnah, which was held on equal weight with the scriptures. And it became ridiculous in terms of the number of things you could or couldn't do, because once you start drawing lines, where are you going to draw them?
So in the Mishnah it was said — and I advise you to take heed of this — don't search your clothes for fleas on the Sabbath, because it's work. And a disabled person who had crutches: would they be allowed to use the crutches? Well, some rabbis thought they should, but some thought they shouldn't, because using your arms in that way on a Sabbath would be work. And so this whole list of rules — in fact, work became codified into 39 different classes, of which reaping was one of them. And that's where this comes from. When the disciples start picking the corn, it attracts the attention of the Pharisees, because they have become wedded to a system.
The Problem with a System
And the problem with a system is it puts blinkers on you. It blinds you as to what it's actually there for in the first place. It blinded them, first of all, to the scriptures — which is why Jesus replies in verse 25: "Have you never read?"
Oh, Jesus. To say that to the Pharisees — "Have you never read the scriptures?" This is their stock in trade. But Jesus wants to make the point to them that they have forgotten what the scriptures are about. And he recounts an incident when David himself had been on the run and no doubt half starving at the time. What does he do? He goes into the temple, and there's some bread there. The bread has been consecrated for the priests, and David takes some and eats it. And Jesus's point is: God didn't tell him off for that. Why are you telling the disciples off for what they're doing now?
But the system had taken over the Pharisees and blinded them to the scriptures. The scriptures, we might note, which put love so highly. Remember how Jesus summarised the whole of the Old Testament law into those two commands: love the Lord your God with all of your heart and soul, mind and strength, and love your neighbour as yourself. And law-keepers never love love, because you can't codify love. You can't measure love. You can't say, "That's enough love." And that's why we need to be careful — careful that we don't become part of a system that blinds us to God and blinds us to each other.
When I first joined a Bible study, not long after becoming a Christian, I thought it was all about a quiz. You know, you go to a pub quiz — well, I went to the Bible quiz once a week with another group of long-suffering people. I thought it was like who could hit the buzzer first, and try and get in with an answer. It was like a competition. Being used to doing exams, that sort of thing — where you break other people's pencils before you go into the exam — I thought this was the same. I didn't realise the point of being there is to love each other, to encourage others who are there.
The Christian life does have a number of elements, tasks, or things to do — church on a Sunday, growth groups, Bible reading. There are important things, really important things. We impoverish ourselves and others when we aren't committed to them. But we should never forget they are never an end in themselves. And they're never to be done without love — not least, love for other people. I don't know if you've had that experience where you've finally managed to get around to opening the Bible, and then someone interrupts you at home and you snap at them. And you realise, gosh, that's not a great combination, is it? Reading the Bible and snapping at someone at the same time. We need to be careful we don't make it into a system that ends up with no love for others.
The Sabbath Was Made for Man
The Sabbath, says Jesus, was made for man. That is, God did it out of love for people. That's why he originally instigated the Sabbath — so that the Israelites would have one day in the week when they were not allowed to do any work. No washing up, no cooking, no cleaning, nothing that counts as work. So you have a day off to focus on God, to remember God the creator and God the saviour. It was given as a gift, given as a blessing, that the nations around might be envious. I think our culture would be similar, wouldn't it? You'd be envious of people: "Gosh, you've got a relaxed day. I wish I had one of those." Well, that's kind of what the Sabbath was like. The people would focus on God. It was a gift out of love for them.
But the system had squashed that gift and made it deadening for people. They were blinded to the scriptures, and worse than that, they were blinded to the Saviour. Verse 28: "So the Son of Man is Lord even of the Sabbath."
He was the Son of Man, the Son of God, who made the Sabbath in the first place. But so obsessed were they about the wretched Sabbath — about what they could and couldn't do, and all the rules, this, that, and the other — they could no longer see who was in front of them. They were blinded to Jesus.
I think back to my own experience of religion. I went to the sort of school where we had chapel — thirteen years, three times a week. That's a lot of chapel. By the end of it, I was absolutely none the wiser about anything to do with God or Jesus. Nothing at all. Now, I don't know what was said — maybe there were good things said, I'm not really sure — but I didn't listen to it. Because it was part of a system. "Don't be late, that's why you need to be there. This is how it runs — Monday, Wednesday, Friday, Sunday, whatever it is. Just be there." So I didn't listen to a word. And it had that effect of blinding me to the scriptures and blinding me to the Saviour.
The Man with the Withered Hand
And that blindness really comes out in this last incident. Have a look at chapter 3, verse 1. Another time he went into the synagogue, and a man with a shrivelled hand was there. Some of them were looking for a reason to accuse Jesus, so they watched him closely to see if he would heal him on the Sabbath. And Jesus said to the man with the shrivelled hand, "Stand up in front of everyone." Then he asked them, "Which is lawful on the Sabbath: to do good or to do evil, to save life or to kill?" But they remained silent.
This time Jesus gets on the front foot. There is a man with this withered hand, and Jesus gets him to stand up in front of everyone and asks them this question: which is lawful on the Sabbath, to do good or to do evil, to save life or to kill? And of course they can't give an answer, because otherwise they will incriminate themselves. And so they remain silent.
And for only the second time in the Gospels, we're told that Jesus became angry. In anger, he was deeply distressed at their stubborn hearts — at the fact that they're so blinded by the system. They should have wanted what was best for the man. They should have had love. But there was no love here.
And so Jesus gets him to stretch out his hand, and he stretched it out, and then we read — amazingly — his hand was completely restored. It was an incredible miracle of healing. We can imagine a gasp of awe from those who were there at the time, and the man himself must have been rejoicing.
But then, in perhaps one of the most shocking verses in the New Testament, verse 6: Then the Pharisees went out and began to plot with the Herodians how they might kill Jesus.
The Jews and the Romans getting together to be rid of Jesus. Why? Because Jesus was a threat — a threat to their system.
Praying for Open Eyes
When I became a Christian, my eyes were lifted and I realised what Jesus had done. And I realised how good the news was. And I thought, wow, this is so amazing. I must tell my friends, because they'll want to know this as well. I thought it's just ignorance that's the problem. If they hear about Jesus, they'll discover it's as wonderful as what I've discovered.
Then I realised pretty quickly it doesn't work like that, because it's not ignorance that is the problem. It's our hearts that are the problem. And within very little time, two of my friends, in public places on different occasions, stood up and yelled at me, shouted at me to shut up.
That's how people see Jesus. You may have had the experience of Jehovah's Witnesses coming to the door, and you try and talk to them, and you realise pretty quickly it doesn't make any difference what you say. It makes absolutely no difference. And the reason is because they're blind. It's like they're looking through a lens. They cannot see it. Blind to the scriptures and blind to Jesus. Conditioned to think that way.
Mind you, that's not so different from how non-religious people think as well. The fact is, it's just hardwired into us — thinking that doing good gets us to heaven, that being right with God depends on what we're like. It's just absolutely baked into us. That's our system. And when you're like that, you can't understand any difference, until God opens our eyes.
And that shows the importance of praying for people. Pray that people would understand their sin and be able to see their Saviour. And as we do so, we should pray for ourselves — that we would not become hard-hearted, that we won't become self-righteous, that being an evangelical church where we have the scriptures open, we wouldn't become blind to what they're saying. Pray for ourselves that we wouldn't lack in love — love for God and love for others. Pray that we wouldn't become those who read but cannot see, who attend but cannot hear, who speak of love but are blind to those in front of us.
It's Jesus who makes the difference. It's Jesus who does what human religion can never do. Christianity is a feast, not a fast. I wonder if joy shines out of your life. Christianity is a saviour, not a system. Does Jesus cause that joy to rise up from within, to radiate out to the people that you mix with during the week?
Let's pray that that would be the case and ask for God's help to make it so.
Dear God in heaven, we thank you for your great love for us. Please forgive us when we're casual or hard-hearted, Lord, when we read but cannot see, when we talk with people but have no love. Pray, Lord, that you would help us to be so grateful for what you've done for us, that we'd be filled with joy and with love for others, we ask. In Jesus' name. Amen.