Tucker Carlson interviews author Thomas Frank on how "creativity" became a tool of elite rationalization
Tucker Carlson speaks with author and historian Thomas Frank about his new book arguing that the word "creativity" has been systematically hijacked to justify plutocracy, deindustrialization, and the rise of a privileged class at the expense of working Americans.
Summary
Tucker Carlson sits down with Thomas Frank, author and historian, to discuss Frank's new book tracing how the concept of "creativity" — once a genuine celebration of human ingenuity — was co-opted after World War II to rationalize tax cuts for the wealthy, the offshoring of manufacturing, financial deregulation, and the elevation of a white-collar elite over working people. Frank argues that every major step in the neoliberal economic transformation of America — from the 1978 capital gains tax cut to the repeal of Glass-Steagall to the rise of Silicon Valley — was justified using the language of creativity and innovation, while actual measurable creativity, productivity growth, and GDP growth all declined. The conversation concludes with both men expressing alarm about artificial intelligence as the culmination of these same trends, with Frank arguing that AI represents the ultimate displacement of genuine human creativity in the name of celebrating it.
Key Takeaways
FULL TRANSCRIPT
Introduction: What Is Creativity, and Why Does the Word Matter?
Tucker Carlson: Tom Frank, thank you for doing this.
Thomas Frank: Tucker Carlson, great to be here.
Tucker Carlson: You've got decades of experience writing books that make people mad.
Thomas Frank: Made them happy, made them laugh.
Tucker Carlson: Exactly. But now you've written a book against creativity. How could you be against creativity?
Thomas Frank: Good question. So I'm not actually against creativity. I'm against the way the word has basically been hijacked and used to excuse — well, I'll do the whole thing really quick here — plutocracy. This word, which is a magical word, a word that describes what is most human and most valuable about us, has been taken over the years and used to describe the American elite. You know, they are creative, they are innovative. Why do they succeed? Because they are innovators. Why should we admire them? Because they are creative. Why should we cut their taxes? Because that's how to get innovation going again. And so on. It's become a kind of word for rationalizing rule by an elite.
Tucker Carlson: What is creativity?
Thomas Frank: Well, the definition that people use is that it's a kind of mental faculty that is analogous to IQ but with two important differences. Everybody can participate. IQ is supposed to be inborn — it's genetic and it doesn't change in the course of your lifetime. The main idea behind creativity is that everybody can do it and you can learn how to do it. Your creativity can change. You can get better at it as you go through life. Now, none of this is particularly scientific and it all pretty much falls apart under scrutiny. But nevertheless, there's a reason that we admire artists and novelists and musicians and people that create, that make new things.
Tucker Carlson: It's the spark of the divine in the human being.
Thomas Frank: Exactly. God created. We're made in his image. Therefore, we create.
Tucker Carlson: It is the most beautiful and human thing, I think, or among them anyway.
Thomas Frank: Yes. The problem is the way the word has been completely and utterly hijacked. And in some ways it's perfect for this kind of linguistic hijacking that I'm talking about, because it's something that we all love. There can be nothing wrong with it. And the same with the word innovation — you see it everywhere. I saw it on a bus on my way up here. It's a bus line called "Innovative." This word is everywhere. And the reason it's everywhere is because we admire it so much. There can be nothing wrong with this. This is the noblest of human faculties. This is what makes our country prosperous. This is supposedly what makes us unique among the nations — that we're a creative people, an innovative people, and this is why our economy is so affluent.
Tucker Carlson: I did notice a change. I noticed it but I didn't understand it as it was happening. Creativity — obviously an undisputed good. But the creative class —
Thomas Frank: There you go.
Tucker Carlson: — is a different thing. So the creative class was always viewed with suspicion, in my perception, by the ruling class. The creative class was this kind of separate, distinct thing. But what if you redefine the creative class and say they are the ruling class? Or you say the ruling class are creative?
Thomas Frank: Well, this is really what happened. There's this huge bestselling book — I think it came out in 2002 — Richard Florida was the author, and it's called The Rise of the Creative Class. The idea is that this is the correct designation for the dominant class in America. But he uses it to describe all sorts of people, not just artists, not just writers, but basically every manner of white-collar professional. Highly educated professionals are, quote unquote, creative, and they're this dominant elite. But because they're creative, we're supposed to look up to them, respect them, admire them, and do these massive public favors for them. And this was the upshot of that book and that theory. And by the way, it's still going. There are cities all over America that are constantly building special tax districts for creatives, supporting all kinds of things — building bike paths, encouraging coffee shops, doing all this stuff to lure creatives to your city, because once you did that, you would have prosperity.
Tucker Carlson: Well, then wouldn't the arts flourish? But the arts have withered.
Thomas Frank: The arts have — yes. Basically gone.
The Decline of Actual Creative Work
Tucker Carlson: The irony that hangs over this book is that while at the very same time we have worshipped at the shrine of creativity and innovation, those things have been dying in this country and we never talk about it.
Thomas Frank: Right. But we all know this is true. I'm a writer. I know a lot of writers. It is the worst time that I can think of to be a writer in America. Prices go up and up and up all the time. What writers get paid goes down and down and down. Look at what's happened to the daily newspaper in every city in America, which used to be the sort of gateway to life as a writer. Look at what's happened to musicians — this is the worst story. The streaming services have made it impossible. I have a friend who was in an indie rock band. They were wonderful, absolutely fabulous, had a certain amount of success. And he told me — or I think he wrote this somewhere — that he now earns less in a year from the streaming services for a song that gets played thousands and thousands of times than he would have gotten for selling a single 45 record back in the day. This is what is happening to musicians. You can't earn a living at it. And look at liberal arts academia — which is what I wanted to spend my life doing, history — it's in a state of collapse. And this is before Trump came along and declared war on it. It was in a state of collapse already. The creative occupations are dying. And this is going on at the same time that we're putting quote-unquote creative people on a pedestal and various presidents and other public figures talk about innovation constantly.
Tucker Carlson: Well, sort of the same way we started to revere the American Indians the second we put them on reservations and they posed no real threat. They became museum pieces and now we can say how awesome they are.
Thomas Frank: I'm not ready for that yet. I'm not a museum piece. Well, I guess I kind of am. But the fundamental tension between the people in charge and the creative class — which has existed forever, in Athens it was real — is that if you are open-minded enough, you might wind up challenging through your ideas the precepts that uphold the order. You are a threat to the people with power.
Tucker Carlson: Yes. That's obviously part of it. But when did the word itself explode?
The Post-War Origins of "Creativity" as a Concept
Thomas Frank: Creativity — this ability that humans have to make things — goes back to the earliest civilizations. But the word itself only became a sort of explosion in the public consciousness after World War II. That's when you started getting theories about creativity and this idea that if you read the right self-help book, you could become a more creative person. There's this huge traffic in self-help books that'll tell you how to be a more creative person — you follow these rules, you drink tea at this time of day, you take a walk, you write in a journal when you get up in the morning. All of that exploded in the late 1940s and early 1950s.
Tucker Carlson: I didn't know that. Why do you think that happened right after the war?
Thomas Frank: Really good question. Part of it is the rise to power of the professional class, which we've been talking about. Another one is the tremendous example during the war of the Manhattan Project, of the atomic bomb, which taught the world — one of many lessons, but one that was taken to heart — that scientific genius was from now on the most important quality in the world. Many of the people who write about creativity refer to that event, to Hiroshima. I think it's a combination of those things. The big corporations were setting up enormous R&D divisions. The government was subsidizing scientific research. And meanwhile, during the war, the Army and the Navy had both done psychological studies of the people they had taken in from the population. All of these things come together and this idea of creativity explodes. First it is psychological studies on draftees and inductees and officers.
Tucker Carlson: What did they find?
Thomas Frank: I don't remember the specifics, but they were always interested in the same thing — high-performing people, people who can accomplish things very efficiently, who can think under pressure. We want more of them. That's always the question: we need more of this kind of people. What was Trump's remark? Our super geniuses — we've got to protect them, we don't have too many of them.
Tucker Carlson: Of course. This is the argument that Silicon Valley has made on H-1Bs.
Thomas Frank: Is that right? Yeah. Well, you see this across the board — these arguments, which seem very humane and seem like they should be helping civilization, have been used across the board for the worst purposes imaginable. What happens is the self-help literature explodes after the war, and then right on its heels comes the psychological literature. Psychologists get into the game: let's study this faculty called creativity. Does it exist? What is it? Who has it? How do we encourage it? And then by the 1960s, there's a very interesting episode along the way called Sputnik. This literature was well known enough by the late '50s that when Sputnik happened in '57, creativity was basically turned to as the answer. This is how America was going to beat the communists in the space race. They had more people than us, they had more scientists than us, they had excellent engineers — but we had creativity. And so at the college and university commencements in early 1958, all of these commencement addresses are about how to encourage creativity. We have to have more creativity. They said "creativity for survival." Adlai Stevenson wrote the introduction to some book back then and said we need innovators, not organization men. So there's this very interesting moment where America turns away from the Red Scare, from McCarthyism, and decides what we really need is the opposite of that. We need nonconformists, we need divergent thinkers, we need individualists, we need rebels — and we need lots of them.
Tucker Carlson: And by the '60s, they got them.
Thomas Frank: They got them. Yeah. In the '60s this doctrine is everywhere.
Tucker Carlson: But it was a top-down idea. I didn't know that.
Thomas Frank: Pretty much. Yes. Absolutely. The main figure behind all of this was an advertising executive — a very well-known, prominent man, one of the principals of an agency called BBDO, one of the big New York agencies. They did the Pepsi commercials when we were kids. He wrote the first big book on creativity. He was the sort of guy who introduced this to the general conversation. It was his personal hobby horse and he succeeded in making it this national fascination. He wrote a series of books, all of them very successful. He organized a group at the University of Buffalo that still exists today and publishes the main academic scholarly journal on the subject — on creativity — still going to this day.
Anyhow, so you get to the '60s. It's actually kind of fun to trace it step by step, because what you find is this glorious idea changing form year after year. It means one thing, then it means another thing.
Tucker Carlson: How often do you see that?
Thomas Frank: Yeah. But the word's magic persists through it all. That's the fascinating thing. It remains this thing that we admire and look up to, and we think we know what is meant by it, but of course we never really do. It changes all the time.
Reagan, Capital Gains, and the Political Weaponization of "Creativity"
Thomas Frank: One of the guys — so I chart the political usage of these terms. Ronald Reagan loved the word creativity. Not sure where he picked it up, probably in his General Electric days, but he actually compiled a book of speeches in the late '60s and the title he gave it was The Creative Society. And when he went to do his big tax cuts in the '80s, if you go back and look at the text — and by the way, you talk a lot about wealth being taxed less than labor — the big piece of legislation that started that, the 1978 capital gains tax cut, was all done to spur creativity and innovation in America. They said this again and again and again.
Tucker Carlson: I would think, just as a non-genius, non-creative person, if you wanted to spur creativity, you would want to incentivize work rather than passive investing.
Thomas Frank: Really good point. But how is creativity used to give preference to passive investing over work? Well, you've put your finger on one of the many ironies of this whole story. In the '70s, the economy began to slow down. You had stagflation, oil crisis, inflation. Everything seemed to go wrong, and one of the many things that seemed to go wrong was that innovation appeared to have slowed down in America. This was not me reading between the lines — this is in the New York Times at the time. There's an innovation crisis in America, mid-'70s. The Washington Post ran stories about it. There were congressional hearings about it. The Carter administration issued a 300-page report on how to get innovation going in America, in 1978. Carter was a very innovation-minded guy — he had been an engineer. He was very concerned about this, but he didn't have any answers. But the nascent supply-side wing of the Republican Party did have an answer. It was really simple: cut capital gains taxes. You cut capital gains taxes, you'll increase the amount of money flowing to venture capital. Do that and you'll get more innovation, more Silicon Valleys. And they did. It was a huge tax cut — the first one in the grand progression of tax cuts we're still doing to this day. The 1978 capital gains tax cut was monumental in significance. It did indeed change the world. It made the stock market immensely more attractive. All kinds of money did indeed flow to venture capital. It did not make us more innovative people — the opposite is what has happened. But it did exactly what you just described: it prioritized investment over manufacturing, over making and doing.
Tucker Carlson: Those are unforeseen consequences — well, actually, those are the most foreseen consequences ever. There may be a basis on which you could defend that if you were looking for a certain goal, like GDP or something. But you would never do that in order to increase creativity.
Thomas Frank: Yeah. Well, they did. And then Reagan did it again. And they do it all the time. They talk about this all the time: we've got to cut capital gains taxes to get creativity moving in this country again. They're still doing it somewhere today. When Reagan did the Kemp-Roth tax cut in '81, if you go back and look at the text, it was explicitly done to encourage creativity in America.
Tucker Carlson: This is to get us out of the doldrums of the 1970s.
Thomas Frank: It turns out — and I didn't know this when I went into writing this book, I was just going to write a history of this idea, I had no idea what can of worms I was opening — it is present at each of the great steps in what you would call the neoliberal turn. At every single one it's there. When you're talking about offshoring manufacturing, it's there. When you're talking about privatizing universities, it's there. They're always talking about innovation, always talking about creativity. This class of people — you have to put them on a pedestal, you have to cut their taxes, you have to build special neighborhoods for them, you have to gentrify your cities. And meanwhile, manufacturing doesn't matter. Not creative. Can go overseas. Who cares?
Tucker Carlson: Well, it's by definition creative because it's actually creating something.
Thomas Frank: You and I know that. You would be astonished at how little ice that argument cut.
The Post-Industrial Society and the Dismissal of Manufacturing
Tucker Carlson: For most of human history, the measure of success, the goal, was not creativity — it was productivity. How many bushels a week can we grow? And the thing about productivity is it's easily measured. You can actually count the bushels. Creativity is harder to measure.
Thomas Frank: In fact, impossible to measure. So they use proxies. And one of them is productivity growth. And I'm going to give away the secret here: since we started worshipping at the shrine of creativity and innovation and doing all of these massive public favors for these people, productivity growth in America has gone through the roof, right, Tucker?
Tucker Carlson: No. I noticed it's half of what it was in the '50s and '60s.
Thomas Frank: Is that true?
Tucker Carlson: Yeah. And GDP growth is the same. I was born in '65. The economy grew over 5% — I think it was 6% that year. If it gets to 3% now, they're popping champagne corks. It never gets that high anymore.
Thomas Frank: It can't on the basis of this kind of economy that we have, that's based on finance. When you offshore a huge part of your actual productive economy — yes. By the way, you said a fascinating thing a minute ago, which is that manufacturing obviously creates. That just seems so obvious to me when I'm reading this stuff. Can I back up a second and tell you how I figured all this out?
So I was driving in my car one day and I had NPR on. They've got a guy and he's complaining about the Trump tariffs — this is a couple of years ago. He's complaining that it's going to make it more expensive for him to import whatever manufactured good he sells in America, to import it from China where he has it made. But then he clarifies right away: "But we keep the creative work here in America. We just do the manufacturing work in China." And he says this as though we all know that's how it works. So I go back and dig into it, and that is the theory. That is what these guys believe. Do you remember "Designed by Apple in California, assembled in China"? They used to put that on everything they made.
Tucker Carlson: Because the creative work was kept here at home, and that was supposed to matter. But the making of things was not creative, so that can go overseas.
Thomas Frank: And by the way, it's false. It's wrong.
Tucker Carlson: Well, it's insane, actually. If I order my housekeeper to make my bed, I can't take credit for a made bed.
Thomas Frank: Good point. But what — I don't know if you followed my writing over the years, but in the old days I used to write a lot about labor. And one of the things you realize real quickly when you talk to guys that work on a shop floor is that they do innovate, and they innovate all the time. The engineers have designed all the machinery, but the workers deal with the machinery. They know the product in a sometimes very intimate way. They know a lot more about it than anybody over in the office building. They have this granular knowledge about what they're doing that is lost when you ship all that overseas. And the idea that because they didn't go to college they're not creative is absurd. It is ridiculous. It makes me angry every day.
Tucker Carlson: Yesterday morning at 7, I watched a friend of mine with a high school education move by himself a garage off its foundation and load it onto a dump trailer and drive it five miles to his house.
Thomas Frank: That's creativity and innovation. And our ancestors back in the days when everybody was a farmer — they innovated constantly. They had to. The idea that you're not creative unless you're a member of this elite group is the most toxic idea. But nevertheless, as I say, it keeps going.
Ronald Reagan, George Gilder, and the Entrepreneur as Creative Hero
Thomas Frank: Shall I keep going with the story?
Tucker Carlson: I love it. Yes. It's the most interesting thing I've heard in a long time.
Thomas Frank: Thank you. When I started writing this, it was all a surprise to me to find all this. I had no idea Ronald Reagan loved the word creativity. And his sort of big thinker of the Reagan White House, George Gilder — do you remember this guy?
Tucker Carlson: Very well.
Thomas Frank: Gilder wrote a book where he made this argument — and he's still alive, I should use the present tense. He makes this argument, I think very forcefully — it's a wrong argument, but he was a good writer — that entrepreneurs are the most creative people of them all. And so what we have to do in this country is make sure that entrepreneurs have resources, have money. And then he went further: entrepreneurs are more creative than artists and writers and musicians, because he said they're less selfish. His arguments were fascinating. They would attack everything that you took for granted. But this was the Reagan years: the entrepreneur is the creative person.
Reagan loved the word creative. Democrats tend to love the word innovative or innovation. Carter was really into innovation. But nobody can top Barack Obama. This is the unwritten story of the Obama administration. When people write histories about Obama, they never mention this, but if you look, he mentions innovation in every single one of his State of the Union addresses. He talks about it constantly. His White House issued three different innovation manifestos. His campaign — I went back and saw on YouTube, in '07 when he was challenging Hillary for the Democratic nomination — he did an event at Google headquarters where he rolled out what he called his innovation agenda. This was very important to him.
Tucker Carlson: I remember this.
Thomas Frank: And the pundits and historians just brush all that off. They think this is an empty word, an empty signifier that means nothing.
Tucker Carlson: No, it's a resonant word.
Thomas Frank: Yes. It was powerful and it meant a lot. And it meant a lot in legislative terms as well. I'll give you an example. In 2011, Obama comes to Osawatomie, Kansas, which is a town south of Kansas City, near where I grew up in Kansas City. And he proceeds to give a speech — a very good speech, one of the Obama classics — where he talks about the decline and fall of the middle class in these Midwestern towns. You go to any town in Kansas and Missouri and you see what he means. The main street is empty, the stores are all boarded up. A way of life has died. And he laments this way of life. He did it in a spectacularly eloquent way. It's my subject, and I wish I could do it as well as he did. He evokes this beautifully. But then he goes to the solution. What's the solution? And he talked about this a lot that year: there's nothing the government can do for those people whose way of life is ending. We have to have more innovation. And the way we get more innovation is we have to have more people go to university and get STEM degrees. You remember that — the STEM subjects.
And so you're looking at this and it's just not an answer. It's not a solution. It's evasion. It's a way of not doing anything. And there's all sorts of things that the federal government could do to keep blue-collar people from being thrown out of the middle class, which is what's happening. There were a million things they could have done back then, and he didn't do them. And neither is Trump, even though now those people are his people.
But why did Obama like this word so much? Think about it and it totally works for him: it sounds like change, it sounds like progress, so it sounds like liberalism. But at the same time, he's telling Google, "I get you, I understand, that's what you're all about." It's the corporate word par excellence. And then the third thing is it gets him off the hook for actually doing anything. There's nothing the government can do. The best the government can do is encourage us to be innovators. Since all progress and all economic growth comes — this is the theory — from innovation, the best he can do is encourage us to innovate.
Tucker Carlson: What a copout.
Thomas Frank: Think of the favors he did for Silicon Valley, which were enormous. Think of the favors he did for Wall Street.
Financial "Innovation" and the Deregulation of Wall Street
Tucker Carlson: Wall Street's not creative.
Thomas Frank: Well, I think if you take a look at the private equity sector, it's just redolent with creativity. You roll into some company that some other family built, just lard it up with debt, and then walk away. That's creative. There are five industries in America that abuse the terms creativity and innovation more than anybody else: advertising, pharma, tech, Wall Street, and defense — the defense contractors. There's a whole chapter in the book about the defense contractors describing themselves as innovative, and it's actually very funny because their language is so grotesque and they just heap it on.
Tucker Carlson: Weapons manufacturers talking about —
Thomas Frank: Yeah. Of course.
Tucker Carlson: People who make napalm.
Thomas Frank: To go back to Wall Street — when they were in the process of deregulating Wall Street in the '90s. You remember this was the great object of the Clinton administrations, right? They were going to deregulate Wall Street and they did. They deregulated them again every year — another bank deregulatory measure, culminating finally in the repeal of Glass-Steagall. It all ended badly. It was a disaster, as many people warned at the time. But if you go back and look at the documents — and it's all online now because the Clinton presidential library is all electronic — why did they do it? Always for financial innovation. This was the term of art they used to describe all these fantastic new financial instruments that these guys were dreaming up. Credit default swaps, mortgage-backed securities.
Tucker Carlson: Seriously?
Thomas Frank: Yes. That's financial innovation. We had to have more of it. It was going to balloon our economy. We're sending manufacturing overseas — this is what we're doing instead.
Tucker Carlson: Just creating Ponzis.
Thomas Frank: Well, you have the benefit of hindsight. But they called it financial innovation. And this is what you have to understand: the word innovation and the word creativity are what I call thought-clichés. You hear this word and you don't inquire. You hear this word and you stop thinking. You're like, "Oh, it's a good thing."
Tucker Carlson: National security. National security. China. China. China.
Thomas Frank: Innovation is better. It is better. It's the story of our times. We worship at this shrine. This is what makes us who we are. This is what makes us prosperous above all people. We're going to do all these things to get more of it. All the things backfire. But on we go.
So while this is going on, in the Obama term, we've already offshored the bulk of American manufacturing. That process is kind of unstoppable by the time he takes office in 2009. And remember, he only became president because of the financial crisis and because of the pain in middle America. So there's this tremendous irony: the guy who comes into office basically elected to do a kind of New Deal sort of act instead dedicates his career to innovation. We need more of this.
But one of the things you also notice is that the innovators get bailed out. The industries that we have designated as innovative and creative always get all kinds of favors. But everybody else goes to the wall. General Motors has to declare bankruptcy. Everybody gets fired.
Tucker Carlson: At least they rescued them. But they didn't give Goldman Sachs that same treatment.
Thomas Frank: No. The crises that got Obama to the White House — and I would also add the Iraq War — but certainly the economic crisis that got him there: deindustrialization and then the global financial crisis were both caused, or at least justified, by the imperative of creativity and innovation.
Tucker Carlson: Rationalized or brushed off or explained away. So how exactly was offshoring manufacturing to Asia justified with the word creativity or innovation?
The Post-Industrial Society Theory
Thomas Frank: Yes, I can explain that. There's a theory these guys developed. One of the fascinating things about this that I did not expect to find is that creativity keeps changing over the decades, and one of the things it developed into was an entire social theory of who we are, where we are in history, and how to organize society. It comes up in the late '60s and the idea is called the post-industrial society. There are all these different people who developed the idea at the same time, including Zbigniew Brzezinski — remember this guy?
Tucker Carlson: Do I remember? Yes.
Thomas Frank: Daniel Bell is one. There's a very famous French journalist — Jean-Jacques Servan-Schreiber. Remember this guy? And all of these guys are coming up with this idea of the post-industrial society.
Tucker Carlson: Brzezinski was one of them. I had no idea.
Thomas Frank: Yeah. He was kind of a geopolitical big thinker. He was national security adviser under Carter, and also in the Defense Department under Johnson. Father of Mika Brzezinski. But a really important figure in modern American history. Another one was Peter Drucker.
So you have a kind of Republican-flavored version where it's all about entrepreneurs, and you have a Democratic-flavored version, which comes mainly from Daniel Bell, which is that it's all about the university. But in both cases it's not about manufacturing. Manufacturing is the past. This is something we don't really need to concern ourselves with anymore. And this idea evolves and evolves. It's still universally accepted to this day. Policymakers all over the world believe this stuff. The post-industrial society is a society that runs on thought, on innovation. What did Obama call it? The knowledge economy. Tony Blair was uniquely dedicated to this in Britain.
It has no place for manufacturing. And it's just left demonstrable destruction in its wake.
Tucker Carlson: Let's be charitable and say it hasn't really panned out.
Thomas Frank: It's like a true disaster. And now the bill is almost due. This conversation two years from now will be even more painful because I think it'll be obvious that it was just one of the great failures ever.
Tucker Carlson: Flesh that out.
Thomas Frank: Everything we're talking about — it hasn't worked. In the old days, how does a country become prosperous? You have capital, you have labor, you have some combination thereof, you have resources, you have regulation, you have labor unions, you share the resources in this way and that. Then in the 1950s and '60s we say, no, there's this other factor, and that factor is creativity and innovation, and it inheres in a social class — if you're Republican, entrepreneurs; if you're a Democrat, the highly educated. And we have to do these spectacular favors for this group. And you can see where this is going: instead of all the other things that used to go to make up prosperity or human flourishing, what we have instead is spectacular inequality, because we've done favor after favor after favor for this group of people.
Mass Affluence, the Middle Class, and What Was Lost
Tucker Carlson: Their rise is not just organic. It's not the product of a meritocracy — they're just smarter than normal people.
Thomas Frank: Well, that is the story — sarcastically, of course. But I don't think people understand the degree to which the rise and fall of various groups is the product of government policy.
Tucker Carlson: People don't get that at all.
Thomas Frank: We think we live in some kind of organic state where nature gave it to us. And when I was a kid, I especially encountered people who thought that government intervention in the economy — through regulation, pure food laws, making labor unions legal — was artificial somehow. But it's all artificial. Everything we do is more or less part of the unfolding of a civilization. It's all who we are. And yes, you and I were born in a society that grew by five to six percent every year, that had incredibly high taxes, that had strong labor unions, and there were strikes all the time when we were kids, and had enforced antitrust laws. Can you believe that? The Johnson administration used to do this routinely. And this was a society where the distance between — what did he call it? — the Great Society. We were all going to be part of the middle class. And Johnson wasn't wrong about that. It was a cliché of the time that you could have a blue-collar person living next door to a white-collar person and the only difference would be in their tastes and their brand names — this guy drove a Chevy, that guy drove a Buick. That was a cliché of the society I was growing up in. And it was mass affluence. I constantly talk to young audiences and they have trouble believing that this existed.
Tucker Carlson: I grew up in it, and I grew up in a rich area among rich people who thought of themselves as upper middle class and who stayed in motels when they traveled to their weekend houses by car. I literally grew up that way.
Thomas Frank: Me too. And I am here to tell you this actually existed. Now it wasn't perfect — there were lots of people that hadn't been brought into it yet. But that was the goal in the '60s: to bring everybody in.
Tucker Carlson: Well, but it also was a very calm society, relatively speaking, despite all the turmoil of the '60s and '70s. People — even liberal people — looked at groups like the Symbionese Liberation Army and thought, what? That's crazy. Because you would want to fix things, maybe we need Head Start, maybe we don't. But revolution? Why would you have revolution? It's a middle-class country.
Thomas Frank: But you can say all that was artificial, all of that was fake, because it was all done with heavy-handed government intervention. And all of that is true. But then taking it apart is also fake. And what we've done — we have been on a race since 1978 to destroy that society. We don't say that. We don't say that's what we're doing. We still talk about how much we love the middle class, but yeah, we've taken it apart. Do you want to hear a funny statistic?
Tucker Carlson: Yes.
Thomas Frank: In 1978 — I was reading an obituary for a guy and it mentioned this — there were two billionaires in America. And they were regarded as kind of eccentric, strange people. Today there's close to a thousand.
Tucker Carlson: What were they? Do you know in 1978?
Thomas Frank: Yeah, I do actually. One was John D. MacArthur — you know, the MacArthur Foundation — and the other was Daniel Ludwig, a shipping fortune. And it was MacArthur's obituary I was reading. He died in '78, that same year as the first big capital gains tax cut.
The Condition of the Creative Class Today
Tucker Carlson: Can we detour into the condition of the creative class? Since I've lived in that class my whole life, the thing that I notice is just how little creativity there is, how much tighter the boundaries are of acceptable thinking, how much more banal the work product is. And how truly creative people are almost instantly penalized or kicked out. If someone really starts thinking freely — like, why are we doing it this way? — it's like, shut up, racist, or shut up, whatever. Just call him a name, make him go away. I almost never hear truly open-minded or creative thinking in public ever.
Thomas Frank: Well, where you do hear it, of course, is on social media, where people will say anything. You can find anything if you look hard enough. But there are some brilliant guys too. And every time I see one of those brilliant guys, even if I don't agree with them, I think, well, that's really smart, that's really original. And then I think, what the hell are you doing on Twitter? Shouldn't you be building a new society?
Tucker Carlson: And the answer is you can't get a job if you think like that.
Thomas Frank: You can't have the kind of literary career that someone would have once. In the old days, you would go work for a newspaper. You'd have a column — it could be a regional paper, the Kansas City Star, a Chicago paper — there were hundreds of these things. It was a smaller number of voices, but the voices were secure because they had a job, they had a contract, they were paid to do what they did. But the props of that way of life have all been pulled out. So if you want to go into any kind of creative writing nowadays, you basically have to have gone to one of a very small number of universities — you can guess which ones, obviously the Ivies. And they live in a little bubble world where they all agree with each other and they write for one another's publications. All the publications are heavily subsidized. Once it requires heavy subsidies, then obviously you're not going to have any kind of real —
Tucker Carlson: But can I just challenge your analysis on one point? You implied that creativity is possible in a society in which people have some security. And yet I don't think anyone has more security than a tenured Ivy League professor. Talk about security. And yet it's ossified. I can't think of any interesting —
Thomas Frank: There are some in the humanities. I wanted to be one of those when I started out. I actually got a PhD in history. I'm not sorry that I didn't go through with it — I like how my life has turned out and I like writing books. But I do miss that they have colleagues, they constantly bounce ideas off each other. There are still some very brilliant people. Do you know anyone who's thinking really outside the box? I don't see any radicalism at all. I see kind of state-approved, Apple-Google-approved radicalism, fake performative radicalism — race radicalism, for example. But I don't see any true free thinking. Maybe I'm missing it.
Tucker Carlson: Yeah. No, it exists. But it's all under threat.
The Collapse of the University
Thomas Frank: The tenure was a great invention in its day, but now it doesn't protect anyone anymore. And the vast majority of people who were my cohort when we got our PhDs — this was in the mid-'90s — became what's called adjuncts. The university has remade itself as a profit-minded organization. So what you have is they bring these people on, they teach classes, they get paid very very little, but they keep with it. They suffer the indignities. They live in their cars. These are adjuncts I'm talking about. I did it for a while. I got paid something like $1,500 for a whole semester — for a lot of work. You can put together two or three of those and maybe earn a living this way. You drive around, you have to — it's not a good way of life. But people stick with it because they think, I've never done anything else in my life but get good grades and write good term papers, and I'm good at this, damn it, and sooner or later they're going to recognize me and I'm going to get the tenure-track job. And they never do. So you've got this enormous population of adjuncts in America who do the majority of teaching. So you know how you pay this extravagant sum for your kid to go to whatever university — they're being taught by adjuncts unless they're very, very careful. That's who does the vast majority of the teaching in this country nowadays. It's this floating population of people who have no job security.
But the upshot of this is: what does this do for creativity? If that's how you're living, you think you're going to write some fantastic breakthrough text? Hell no.
Tucker Carlson: What percent? That's so interesting.
Thomas Frank: But you know where the university's resources have gone? They've totally screwed the professoriate — and every university professor in America will tell you horror stories about this. Where the money has gone is they now have this enormous population of administrators. I was talking to a professor friend of mine at Stanford the other day and she told me that the ratio of administrators to undergraduate students at Stanford is now one to one.
Tucker Carlson: What do they do?
Thomas Frank: I don't know. They don't write books. They're not doing the creative work of academia. And this is everywhere — every university is like this now, huge numbers of administrators. And the federal dollars flowing into these places — and not for breakthrough cancer research — are really high.
Tucker Carlson: Yes. Oh yeah, absolutely. Trump has declared war on them, which is very frightening. What would be nice is if instead of doing that, he actually knew what the problem was and tried to do something to fix it.
But can I ask — if they have enough money to hire administrators for every student, if they're getting billions in federal funding directly or indirectly, if the student loans are guaranteed by taxpayers — why are they charging families 80 grand a year to send their kids to this counterproductive experience?
Thomas Frank: There's a lot of different answers to that. One is that they say they need the money — though most of them actually don't. One is because that's who they are now. They have changed their mission. You and I are old enough to think of the university as a charitable institution, something that cares about you. But that role, that mission, is actually long gone. And creativity had a hand in undoing that as well. This is a fascinating story — nobody knows this. It was front-page news at the time, but it's utterly forgotten. There was a law passed in 1980 called the Bayh-Dole Act. Do you remember this?
Tucker Carlson: Bayh-Dole.
Thomas Frank: Birch Bayh from Indiana and Bob Dole from Kansas. The idea was to encourage — again, this is part of the response to the innovation crisis of the '70s — to make it easier for universities to patent scientific research, mainly meaning pharmaceuticals. And this has proven to be an incredible bonanza for universities. They now hire lobbyists to protect their patents on drugs. But it also transformed the university into a more mercenary institution — a huge real estate operation. They build office buildings right next to campus and call it an innovation center. And you're paying for the privilege to be part of this class, to join this class. That can't just be open to everyone. They have to extract some value for that. And I think they could raise the price much higher and people would continue to pay it.
There's also a really gross explanation — a liberal version of this — where they had a model they called "high tuition, high aid," where they would be a welfare state unto themselves. They would decide who gets in. Everybody has to pay this enormous price tag, but we're going to let some people off. So they get to play government all on their own. This was a lot of well-meaning people who thought this was a good idea. And now they'll basically all tell you that was a disaster. That didn't work. Instead, we've put generations of students into incredible amounts of debt.
Tucker Carlson: Unpayable debt.
Thomas Frank: Unpayable debt. It's like a mortgage, only you can't sell the house.
Tucker Carlson: Do you remember what it cost to go to the University of California in the '60s?
Thomas Frank: Nothing.
Tucker Carlson: Yeah. It was free if you were in state.
Thomas Frank: And it was excellent. And if you were out of state, it was very very cheap.
Tucker Carlson: And now what is it? It's on par with everything else.
Thomas Frank: Yeah. Of course. When I went to the University of Virginia in the '80s, I got out $7,000 in debt and I was like, damn, that's the most money ever. How am I ever going to pay that off? But it's nothing by comparison to what's being done to the current generation. Some universities are at 80 or 90 thousand, and some have broken a hundred thousand — all costs, not just tuition.
Innovation's Actual Record: Has It Delivered?
Tucker Carlson: What is the measurable effect? How much actual innovation has there been?
Thomas Frank: They have invented a lot of drugs. And look, we're living in the age of the internet, the smartphone, the revolution in AI is coming. There have been all of these revolutions in technology. But truth be told, they pale beside the really amazing, earthshattering innovations of, say, the late 19th century to the 1970s. There's an economist at Northwestern, Robert Gordon, who has written a whole book about this — quite a long book, but an excellent book about the history of invention in America. Things like the electric light, the car, indoor plumbing, airplanes — they revolutionized life in a way that the internet, for all of its amazing things, doesn't even come close to. What you see is that innovation in physical things that we make and systems that we build has really slowed. We still drive around in cars. Cars are better now, but it's still cars. We still ride in jet planes when we travel, as we did when you and I were children.
Tucker Carlson: Did you see this? We bombed Iran with B-52s.
Thomas Frank: Planes built before we were born.
Tucker Carlson: Long before.
Thomas Frank: And by the way, the jets have not gotten faster.
Tucker Carlson: That's right.
Thomas Frank: The 707 was faster than whatever jet you fly on now.
Tucker Carlson: Is that true?
Thomas Frank: It is true. But they say the modern ones are designed to conserve fuel — they don't use as much gasoline. And that's true. But the upshot of all this is that innovation outside of the internet, outside of computers and telecommunications, seems to have slowed down. We don't really know why.
Tucker Carlson: Maybe because we've abandoned the physical world in favor of the theoretical world.
Thomas Frank: Or the fantasy world, if you will. But this is shown in the statistics — productivity statistics, economic growth every year, way below what it was in the '50s and '60s.
Tucker Carlson: But also at the human level. If we're so brilliant and innovative, why don't we innovate a way out of people dying of drug overdoses in public parks?
Thomas Frank: That would require the state.
Tucker Carlson: We're using the state — to prop up Silicon Valley and the weapons manufacturers.
Thomas Frank: I was wondering when we were going to get there.
Tucker Carlson: I'm not even arguing against that, though I could. I'm just saying, as long as you're paying for all this innovation, how about reducing the suicide rate a little bit? There seems to be no meaningful effort to figure out why all these people are killing themselves.
Thomas Frank: By the way, the rolling back of the ambitions of government was also part of the innovation brief. Do you remember in the Clinton years — and this is something people traditionally looked to the Democratic Party for — they were deciding, no, we don't want to do that anymore. They had a plan, a sort of manifesto. It was called "Reinventing Government." Do you remember this? The idea was you outsource everything. And that was — you guessed it — innovation.
Tucker Carlson: But can I just disagree a little bit? I don't think the ambitions have been reduced. I think they've been expanded, but they've just been changed. The idea that you would want to keep people from dying of drug overdoses in public places — that's a big ambition. But bringing democracy to the rest of the world, building data centers the size of Rhode Island — I actually think they're more grandiose in their goals than they've ever been.
Thomas Frank: Yes. It's funny when you put it that way, because it's just a change of perspective and a change of who they care about.
Tucker Carlson: Well, exactly. But it's not like they have smaller ambitions. They have bigger ambitions. We're going to run the world, we're going to make it safer. They wanted to do that back in the Cold War days. But we were all going to be on board.
Thomas Frank: We were in a global competition with the Soviets, and we had to show the third world — that was the object of the Cold War — who's going to win over all these nonaligned countries. We had to prove to them that we cared about the least among us, that everybody in America had a shot, that we were a decent society, a society that your country could look to and admire and want to be like. And that pressure is all off.
Tucker Carlson: That's one of the big explanatory reasons people give for why we just gave up on it all — the Great Society, organized labor, having a decent society for working people to live in. And you think part of the answer is because we had no competition, no one to impress anymore.
Thomas Frank: That's certainly part of the answer. But it's much bigger, because all of this begins while the Cold War was still in full effect. Everything has its roots back in the '50s and '60s.
Why Silicon Valley Gets Preference Over Manufacturing
Tucker Carlson: So why give preference to Silicon Valley over traditional manufacturing, which the government has done?
Thomas Frank: The short answer is because they're creative, because they innovate.
Tucker Carlson: Fuel injection is pretty creative and innovative.
Thomas Frank: There's so much actual innovation in manufacturing at all levels. I worked in a baked bean factory. There was a ton of innovation in the baked bean factory.
Tucker Carlson: By the way, do you know that the Chinese know this?
Thomas Frank: They have not fallen for the post-industrial ideology. They understand that a lot of innovation and improvement comes off the shop floor — that when you build things, you learn how to build things better, you learn how to build other things. There are all sorts of doors that open up from the manufacturing process. It's not something to be sneered at and dismissed just because you don't like the people who work there, which is what we've done.
Tucker Carlson: Can I ask how the media went along with this? How do you wind up going from a society that celebrates hard work, actual innovation, real creativity — World War II, remember Rosie the Riveter, working-class people were heroes — and then you wind up in a world where people who literally collect interest payments for a living become the heroes? But in order for that to happen at the level of public relations, you need a compliant media willing to tell that story.
Thomas Frank: And by the way, you're now talking about venture capital or —
Tucker Carlson: I'm talking about the whole thing. A society based on collecting interest payments is an ignoble society, and the people who do it have always been reviled throughout all of history. The New Testament is all about how tax collectors are bad. This is not a new thing. How do you wake up in a world where tax collectors are great? The guy who is collecting the vig on the loan — the loan shark — is now the hero.
Thomas Frank: Because he makes innovation possible. That is the answer.
Tucker Carlson: That is the payday loan guy.
Thomas Frank: That is — oh my god. That is a financial innovation.
Tucker Carlson: Payday loans.
Thomas Frank: Yeah. And you know how they justify it? It's getting money to people who couldn't get money from a bank. They couldn't take out a loan anywhere else. Look, they're filling a —
Tucker Carlson: Do you know how many RICO suits were filed against the Genovese family for loan sharking at lower interest rates? A lot. Those guys went to prison for it.
Thomas Frank: Sure. Of course. But to get back to the operations of capital — of course they rationalize it this way, that they're subsidizing innovation, they make innovation happen. That's all they talk about. That's how they describe themselves. That's how they think of themselves.
By the way, we were talking about the bailouts — I had to go to South by Southwest for the book. I spent the whole ten-day thing there. I witnessed it all. But while I was there, Silicon Valley Bank failed. And so this is a gathering of people who call themselves creatives — from advertising, from tech, from finance, from all the industries we've been talking about. Silicon Valley Bank fails. And they're like, "Oh no." And you know, these are the kinds of people who actually have their money there. They bailed it out. The US government bailed it right out, immediately. Whenever innovation is involved, whenever you say the magic word "Silicon Valley," you're going to be getting a bailout. That operation is going to get to continue. But I thought — doesn't that kind of undercut the whole justification for the entrepreneurship class, which is that these are risk-takers, these are mavericks?
Tucker Carlson: Of course it does.
Thomas Frank: None of this — it's all transparently — but only once you begin digging into it and looking at it. And this is why I write books like this. So that we can see what's been done to us and how they did it. That's the first step in any kind of recovery.
Tucker Carlson: I just want to say that there's nothing — probably more than almost anything other than love — that I admire more than creativity. And that's why this is such a sad thing to hear from you.
Thomas Frank: But that's why it's unfolded the way it has.
Tucker Carlson: I know. Because the word is exactly that — it's the most beautiful thing. And the fact that it's been used to justify bombs and payday loans is —
Thomas Frank: And wait — you know what's coming?
Tucker Carlson: AI.
AI as the Culmination of the Creativity Ideology
Thomas Frank: So let's — can you handle this conversation emotionally?
Tucker Carlson: I'm going to have to. We all are.
Thomas Frank: We talked about this at breakfast, but I think — and you said what I feel — the subject is so upsetting it's hard even to talk about it sometimes.
Tucker Carlson: Especially for you and me. I'm in the crosshairs. My skill is writing. It's now an automated skill, as of about a year ago.
Thomas Frank: You've got an inherent conflict.
Tucker Carlson: That's one way of putting it. So it is upsetting. And also there's a lot that's unknown — we don't actually know where this is going. But we know what it's done so far, which has been transformative already.
Thomas Frank: But it's also the culmination of the trends that you have been describing for the last hour. It is of a piece with all of this. It's like destroying human beings in the name of preserving human creativity. And all of this talk of godlike creatures —
Tucker Carlson: I watched your interview with Sam Altman. What is the right biblical metaphor here? And what it is is Adam. They're creating a silicon Adam and they are instructing it to take dominion over the earth.
Thomas Frank: Yes. And the fishes and the birds and the animals and also us.
Tucker Carlson: Yes. And they're pretty explicit. Someone sent me last night — actually a big tech guy in Silicon Valley who's very pro-human and a decent man — sent me the Anthropic constitution for AI that grants the AI, the machine it is building, rights as an individual and says that we're not going to make any decision without running it by the AI, and if the AI disagrees, then it's invalid. Treating the AI as a living thing — in fact, as a superior thing. That whole worldview is —
Thomas Frank: It's terrifying. And there's a scene at the end of my book where all the tech execs get together with Donald Trump and they're in the White House, sitting around a big table — much like this one, although I imagine gold-plated. And they go around the table, the tech execs, all the Silicon Valley billionaires, and they take turns flattering Trump. And every single one of them thinks to lard their flattery with the word innovation. "Thank you, Mr. President, for being such a great president and caring about American innovation." The next one: "Mr. President, you and I are going to take American innovation to the next level." Every single one of them does this. This is the doctrine.
What's funny is Trump himself doesn't particularly — he said we're going to bring us into a new golden age of American innovation. But his favorite word is not innovation and it's not creativity. It's genius. He likes the word genius, which is very much a throwback to the 19th century, pre-all of this stuff. He's thinking Napoleon, Goethe —
Tucker Carlson: Nietzsche. Or maybe he's not thinking that. I'd be astonished if Trump had read Nietzsche.
Thomas Frank: Nietzsche is pretty accessible, actually — great writer. But anyhow. The great logic is unfolding: the most creativity, the most admirable thing about the human being, is now going to supplant us. Or maybe it isn't — it's not a perfect technology, it gets things wrong all the time. I was unable to use it for my research for this book because it doesn't know history in any kind of granular way. It knows the broad sweep of things, but if you're writing something new, it's not going to be able to help you with that.
Tucker Carlson: Well, no, because it's an amalgamation of other people's opinions.
Thomas Frank: Exactly. So if you're doing anything novel, it's going to puzzle it.
We've brushed off over the decades working people who are seeing their way of life end, and we say, you know what it is? You're Luddites. And that's always the term.
Tucker Carlson: And that's bad, right?
Thomas Frank: Yeah. We always think that's bad in our society. And now it's all of us.
Tucker Carlson: I support the Luddites strongly and I'm not ashamed at all. Say what you will about the Luddites — they knew that they were about to be destroyed and they tried to fight back. And everybody should. Don't get on the freight car. And we are. And I don't understand why.
Thomas Frank: Part of it's our leadership.
Tucker Carlson: Part of it's us, though, unfortunately.
Thomas Frank: Part of it is us. But do you think it would make any difference? Silicon Valley supported Hillary by 70 to 1 in terms of donations over Trump in '16. For '24, they completely flipped sides. He is, at some point, their man.
Tucker Carlson: Of course.
Thomas Frank: And I don't see him doing what needs to be done.
Tucker Carlson: No. And I'm not sure I see the Democrats doing what needs to be done either. I mean, think of Obama and Google — he loved those guys. The White House was filled with former Google employees towards the end. I was in New York the other day when I was having nightmares about this, and I was walking down the street and it was a beautiful sunny day in Manhattan and it looked just like it always does. People are going about their jobs just like they always do. You follow the crowd and you ride on the subway and you do all the things that you've always done. And it's hard to believe — in fact, it's impossible to believe — that this way of life is threatened.
Thomas Frank: Do you think that it is?
Tucker Carlson: I don't know what to think. I know it's already making an impact here and there. I don't know what's going to happen. I know you can generate content, quote unquote, with a click of a button now. My kids tease me all the time — they write stuff and have ChatGPT or whatever generate stuff in the style of Thomas Frank. Is it good?
Thomas Frank: No. It's terrible.
Tucker Carlson: Do you agree with it, though?
Thomas Frank: No. I like to think — now maybe I'm wrong — but I like to think that I'm a subtle thinker or something like that. And its version of me is like social realist propaganda from the '30s. And maybe that's how the outside world sees me, and maybe they're right. But that's not how I see myself. So no, it's insulting. I'm like, that's not me. I don't write like that. I'm unique and interesting. I'm creative.
Tucker Carlson: So good. Well, I think you are creative and I think this book is amazing. And I don't know if anybody's ever going to celebrate this book, but it's hard — you have to understand it if we're going to change where we're going.
Thomas Frank: I couldn't agree more.
Tucker Carlson: I just think the constituency for your ideas is broad, but there's sort of no overlap with anyone in power.
Thomas Frank: Well, that's okay. You spoke truth, my friend. That is exactly right. That is for sure.
Tucker Carlson: Tom Frank, thank you for doing this. I appreciate it.
Thomas Frank: This has been a blast. Thanks for having me.
Tucker Carlson: It has been for me. Thank you. Incredible.